A private investment in public equity (PIPE) is a transaction in which a company whose shares are already publicly traded sells new shares, or securities convertible into shares, directly to a small group of investors. The sale is a private placement: it is not registered with the securities regulator at the time and is not offered to the general public. Buyers are typically hedge funds, mutual funds, private equity firms and other institutions.
Companies use PIPEs to raise capital faster and with less disclosure work than a public follow-on offering requires. They are most common among smaller listed companies, which may find a conventional underwritten offering costly or unavailable, but large companies have also used them to raise funds quickly in a crisis.
How a PIPE works
The company, usually through a broker-dealer acting as placement agent, approaches a limited number of investors in confidence. Those who agree to hear the details are bound to keep them private and not to trade until the deal is announced. The parties sign a purchase agreement, the company announces the transaction and the money is paid, often within days or a few weeks.
In the United States the sale relies on an exemption from the Securities Act of 1933, generally the private offering exemption and the safe harbour in Regulation D, so buyers must normally qualify as an accredited investor. The securities issued are restricted and cannot be resold freely. The company therefore undertakes to file a resale registration statement soon after closing, and once it is effective the investors may sell on the market. Failing that, they may sell after the holding period in Rule 144.
Pricing and example
Because the buyers take securities they cannot sell at once, PIPEs are priced below the market. The discount is:
where is the market price and is the offer price in the placement.
Suppose a company has 50 million shares trading at $10.00 and raises $45 million by selling 5 million new shares at $9.00. The discount is percent. After the deal there are 55 million shares, and the new investors own percent. Existing shareholders suffer dilution, both in their percentage holding and, because the shares were sold below market, in value per share. Investors often receive warrants to buy further shares as an added inducement.
Types
- Traditional PIPE. Common shares, or preferred shares and notes convertible at a fixed price, are sold at a set discount. The investor bears the market risk after signing.
- Structured PIPE. The securities convert at a price that floats with the market, often with a reset if the share price falls. A falling price hands the investor more shares, which can feed further selling in what is known as a death spiral.
- PIPE alongside a merger. A SPAC commonly arranges a PIPE to close with its acquisition, to replace cash withdrawn by redeeming shareholders. This use grew rapidly in 2020 and 2021.
A related transaction, the registered direct offering, is marketed in the same way but uses an existing shelf registration, so the buyers receive freely tradable shares.
Rules and enforcement
Stock exchange rules limit the size of discounted placements. Both the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq generally require shareholder approval before a company issues shares equal to 20 percent or more of its outstanding stock in a private sale below a defined minimum price.
News of a pending PIPE is material information that has not been made public, since the announcement usually pushes the share price down. An investor who is told of the deal and then sells or shorts the shares before the announcement may commit insider trading. The Securities and Exchange Commission brought a series of cases in the 2000s against funds that did so, and against investors who engaged in short selling before the resale registration was effective and then covered with the PIPE shares.
Advantages and criticisms
For the issuer the attractions are speed, certainty and confidentiality. There is no public marketing period during which the share price can drift, and the company can choose its investors. Costs are generally lower than for an underwritten offering.
The drawbacks fall mainly on existing shareholders, who are diluted at a discount and are usually given no chance to take part. A PIPE can also signal that the company could not raise money on better terms. Studies have found that shares of small companies issuing structured PIPEs tended to perform poorly afterwards, though the cause may lie as much in the weak condition of those issuers as in the financing itself.