Price index formulas are the rules statisticians use to combine the price changes of many goods and services into a single price index. They differ mainly in their weights: whether the quantities or spending shares come from the base period, the current period, an earlier weight period, or an average of periods. The choice matters because buyers shift towards goods that become relatively cheaper. Statistics offices, central banks and researchers use these formulas for the consumer price index (CPI), producer prices, GDP deflators and international comparisons.
The starting point is the Laspeyres price index, which prices a fixed base-period basket. The formulas below are its main alternatives. Throughout, and are the prices of item in the base period and the current period, and and are the matching quantities. A two-item example is used: item A rises in price from 2 to 3 while its quantity falls from 10 to 8; item B stays at 5 while its quantity rises from 4 to 6. The Laspeyres index for this example is 50 divided by 40, or 1.25.
Paasche Price Index
The Paasche price index, devised by the German statistician Hermann Paasche in 1874, weights price changes by current-period quantities. It compares the cost of today's basket at today's prices with the cost of the same basket at base-period prices:
In the example, the current basket costs at current prices and at base prices, so the index is 54 divided by 46, about 1.174, a rise of 17.4%. Laspeyres gives 25% for the same data. The gap is typical: because buyers have already shifted towards the item whose relative price fell, a Paasche index tends to show lower inflation than a Laspeyres index, the two bounding the true change from either side. Paasche needs current quantity data every period, which is costly to collect, so it is used mainly in national accounts, where an implicit GDP deflator is often of Paasche form.
Fisher Ideal Price Index
The Fisher ideal price index, named after the American economist Irving Fisher, is the geometric mean of the Laspeyres and Paasche indices:
Here is the Laspeyres index and the Paasche index. In the example, , a rise of about 21.1%, between the two. Fisher called it ideal because it passes more of the standard tests of a good index than its rivals, including the time reversal test (going forward then back gives exactly 1) and the factor reversal test (the price index times the matching quantity index equals the change in total value). It is also a superlative index, using both periods' weights symmetrically. Since 1996 the US Bureau of Economic Analysis has used chain-type Fisher indices for real GDP and its price measures, as well as for the PCE price index. The same formula applied to quantities gives the Fisher volume index.
Tornqvist Index
The Törnqvist index, named after the Finnish statistician Leo Törnqvist, is a weighted geometric mean of price relatives, where each weight is the average of the item's expenditure share in the two periods:
Here and are item 's shares of total spending in the base and current periods. In the example, item A's share is 0.5 in the base period and 24 divided by 54, about 0.444, in the current one, so its average weight is about 0.472. Only A's price changed, by a factor of 1.5, so the log index is , and the index is about 1.211, almost exactly the Fisher result. The Törnqvist is superlative and is a discrete approximation to the Divisia index. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics uses it for the chained CPI. The same formula with quantity relatives gives the Törnqvist volume index, used in productivity accounts.
Walsh Price Index
The Walsh price index, proposed by the American economist Correa Moylan Walsh, is a fixed-basket index whose basket quantities are the geometric means of the base-period and current-period quantities:
In the example the Walsh weights are for item A and for item B. The basket then costs about 51.33 at current prices and 42.38 at base prices, an index of about 1.211, again very close to Fisher and Törnqvist. Because it treats both periods equally, the Walsh index is symmetric and passes the time reversal test, and it is superlative. It has a practical appeal over Fisher: it is a pure basket index, so it can be explained as the cost of one well-defined basket at two sets of prices. It is used less often in official statistics, but the international CPI manual discusses it as a target index.
Marshall-Edgeworth Price Index
The Marshall-Edgeworth price index, associated with the British economists Alfred Marshall and Francis Ysidro Edgeworth, values a basket whose quantities are the simple average of the base-period and current-period quantities:
The division by two cancels out, so the sums can use the total quantities. In the example the average basket is 9 units of A and 5 of B; it costs 52 at current prices and 43 at base prices, an index of about 1.209. Like Walsh, the formula is symmetric and sits between Laspeyres and Paasche. It is not superlative, however, and it has a known weakness in comparisons between countries of very different size: the arithmetic average of quantities lets the larger economy's basket dominate, so a comparison between a large and a small country mostly reflects the large one's spending pattern. Methods such as the EKS method are preferred in the International Comparison Program.
Lowe Price Index
The Lowe price index, named after the English writer Joseph Lowe, prices a fixed basket of quantities taken from a weight period that may differ from the price reference period 0:
Here are the quantities from the weight period, usually a household expenditure survey covering a year. If that survey showed 12 units of A and 3 of B, the basket costs now and in the reference period, giving about 1.308. Laspeyres and Paasche are special cases in which the weight period equals the base or the current period. Most national CPIs are Lowe-type indices in practice, because spending surveys take time to process, so the basket always comes from a year or two before the price reference month. Statistics offices usually price-update the survey weights to the reference period before use, and update the basket of goods regularly to limit bias.
Young Index
The Young index, named after the English writer Arthur Young, is a weighted arithmetic average of price relatives, using expenditure shares from an earlier weight period . It is also known as the weighted arithmetic average index:
Here is item 's share of spending in the weight period. If the shares were 0.6 for A and 0.4 for B, the index is . The Young index differs from the Lowe index in one key respect: it applies weight-period spending shares directly, without price-updating them to the price reference period. Only if the weight period and the reference period coincide is it the same as Laspeyres. Because spending shares shift as relative prices change, a Young index can drift away from a fixed-basket index. Some countries use Young-type weighting at the upper levels of their CPI; how prices are combined within the lowest-level cells is covered under elementary aggregates and unweighted index formulas.
Divisia Index
The Divisia index, developed by the French economist François Divisia in the 1920s, treats prices and quantities as changing continuously over time. Its growth rate at each instant is the share-weighted average of the growth rates of individual prices:
Here is item 's current share of total spending. The index level is found by adding up, or integrating, these instantaneous changes along the path between two dates. Real data come only at intervals, so the Divisia index cannot be computed directly; discrete formulas approximate it, and the Törnqvist index is the standard approximation, which is why it is sometimes called a discrete Divisia index. The approach is also the basis of Divisia monetary aggregates, developed by William Barnett, which weight each type of money, such as cash or savings deposits, by its user cost instead of simply adding the balances, so that money held mainly as savings counts less than money used for spending.
Superlative Index
A superlative index is an index-number formula that gives exactly the true cost-of-living index, or the true volume index, for a flexible functional form of preferences or technology, one that can approximate any well-behaved pattern of substitution to the second order. The term was introduced by the Canadian economist W. Erwin Diewert in 1976. The Fisher, Törnqvist and Walsh indices are all superlative. They share two features: they use weights from both the base and the current period, and they treat the two periods symmetrically. In practice superlative indices tend to give very similar results, as the worked example shows, all close to 1.211, between Laspeyres at 1.25 and Paasche at 1.174. Because they need current-period weights, they are often published with a lag, as with the chained CPI in the United States. A true cost-of-living index allows for substitution, and a fixed-basket index that does not suffers the bias discussed under index number bias and tests.
How the formulas compare
| Formula | Weights | Type | Example result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Laspeyres | Base-period quantities | Fixed basket | 1.250 |
| Paasche | Current-period quantities | Fixed basket | 1.174 |
| Fisher | Both periods | Superlative | 1.211 |
| Törnqvist | Average spending shares | Superlative, geometric | 1.211 |
| Walsh | Geometric mean of quantities | Superlative, fixed basket | 1.211 |
| Marshall-Edgeworth | Average quantities | Symmetric, fixed basket | 1.209 |
| Lowe | Weight-period quantities | Fixed basket | Depends on weights |
| Young | Weight-period spending shares | Arithmetic average | Depends on weights |
Ref 1100001826