A patronage refund is a payment or allocation by a cooperative to its members out of its surplus, made in proportion to the amount of business each member did with the cooperative during the year rather than in proportion to the capital each member contributed. It is also called a patronage dividend or patronage distribution. A farm supply cooperative might return part of its surplus according to how much each farmer bought; a consumer cooperative according to members' purchases; a financial cooperative according to the interest members paid on loans or earned on savings.
The idea expresses the cooperative principle of member economic participation: surpluses belong to the members who generated them through their use of the business. It distinguishes cooperatives from companies owned by shareholders, where profits are distributed as a dividend based on shares held. Patronage refunds are paid by agricultural, retail, housing, utility and financial cooperatives, including credit unions and other member-owned financial institutions.
How a patronage refund is calculated
Each year, after covering costs and setting aside reserves, the board of a cooperative decides how much of the net surplus from member business to distribute. Each member's share is then calculated as:
- is the patronage refund to member .
- is the surplus the board allocates for patronage refunds.
- is the value of member 's business with the cooperative, such as purchases or interest paid.
- is the total value of business with all members on the same basis.
Suppose a credit union decides to return 2 million dollars to borrowers, and members paid a total of 30 million dollars of loan interest during the year. A member who paid 1,500 dollars of interest receives 2,000,000 multiplied by 1,500 divided by 30,000,000, or 100 dollars. In effect the member's loan cost about 6.7 per cent less than the stated rate for the year.
Cash and retained allocations
A refund need not be paid entirely in cash. Many cooperatives pay part in cash and allocate the rest to the member's capital account, to be repaid in later years. This is a common way for cooperatives, which cannot sell shares to outside investors, to build capital in proportion to use, and it links patronage to cooperative capital adequacy. Some cooperatives revolve retained allocations, repaying the oldest each year, while others hold them until a member leaves or retires. The share retained, and when it is repaid, is set by the board within the cooperative's bylaws and is one of the main governance decisions under the cooperative governance model.
Use in financial cooperatives
Credit unions usually return surplus through higher member dividend allocation on savings or lower loan rates, but some also pay explicit interest refunds to borrowers or bonus dividends to savers, which are forms of patronage refund. In the United States, the institutions of the Farm Credit System, which are cooperatives owned by their borrowers, are well known for paying patronage distributions to farmers and rural businesses, often partly in cash and partly as allocated equity. Some cooperative banks in Europe and elsewhere pay similar distributions.
Tax treatment in the United States
US federal tax rules for most cooperatives are found in Subchapter T of the Internal Revenue Code. In broad terms, a cooperative may deduct qualifying patronage refunds from its taxable income, provided they are paid under a pre-existing obligation and on the basis of business done with members. The member then reports the refund as income where it relates to business expenses, such as farm supplies, but generally not where it relates to personal purchases. Retained allocations can qualify for this treatment if the member agrees to include them in income, and a minimum part of the refund is paid in cash. The effect is a single level of tax on cooperative surplus, avoiding the double taxation of corporate profits and dividends. Credit unions are themselves exempt from federal income tax, so these rules matter less for them. Details are administered by the Internal Revenue Service.
Other countries
Patronage refunds have a long history. The Rochdale Society of Equitable Pioneers, founded in England in 1844, paid a dividend on members' purchases, and the "divi" became a familiar feature of British consumer cooperatives. Canada, Australia and other countries have their own rules on when patronage refunds can be deducted for tax. Across jurisdictions, the key features are the same: the refund must be tied to members' business with the cooperative, decided by the board after reserves are set aside, and kept separate from any return on capital, which cooperative principles say should be limited.