Obsolete US coin denominations are the coin values that the United States once issued but no longer makes, such as the half dime, the two-cent piece, the twenty-cent piece and the trade dollar. Each was created by Congress for a particular need, from a shortage of small change to competition in foreign trade, and each was dropped when that need passed or the coin proved unpopular.
Their stories show how the United States coin denominations in use today were settled through trial and error. Most of these coins were abolished or ended by the Coinage Act of 1873, a broad reform of US coinage that also shaped the long debate over bimetallism and silver. Other discontinued coins include the half cent, the large cent and the three-cent pieces, while discontinued gold values are covered under US gold coin denominations. Old coins of these types are no longer made but are studied by historians and collectors.
Half Dime
The half dime was a small silver coin worth five cents, struck by the United States Mint from the mid-1790s until 1873. Its forerunner was the half disme of 1792, a small issue struck in the year the Mint was founded and often described as one of the first coins produced under the new federal coinage law. Regular half dimes followed, carrying a series of Liberty designs over the decades.
Because it contained silver close to its face value, the half dime tended to disappear from circulation when silver prices rose, a pattern explained by Gresham's law. During the Civil War, silver coins were hoarded and largely vanished from use. In 1866 Congress authorised a five-cent coin made of copper-nickel, the coin now called the nickel, which did the same job with cheaper metal. The Coinage Act of 1873 ended the half dime, leaving the nickel as the only five-cent coin.
Two-Cent Piece
The two-cent piece was a bronze coin issued from 1864 to 1873. It was created during the Civil War, when people hoarded specie and small change became scarce, so that merchants were short of coins for everyday purchases. The Coinage Act of 1864 authorised it alongside a change of the cent to a lighter bronze alloy.
The two-cent piece is notable as the first circulating US coin to carry the motto IN GOD WE TRUST, which later spread to other coins. Production was heavy at first but fell quickly. The arrival of the nickel three-cent piece in 1865 and the nickel five-cent piece in 1866 gave the public more convenient values, and the two-cent coin fitted awkwardly between the cent and the larger coins. Once the coin shortage eased, demand dried up, and the Coinage Act of 1873 abolished the denomination.
Twenty-Cent Piece
The twenty-cent piece was a silver coin authorised in 1875 and struck only until 1878, making it one of the shortest-lived US denominations. Supporters argued that it would help with making change, especially in the West, where small coins were in short supply.
The coin failed largely because it was too similar to the quarter. Both were silver, close in size and carried a seated figure of Liberty on the front. The twenty-cent piece had a plain edge rather than a reeded one, but the difference was easy to miss, and people often confused the two coins in daily use. Business strikes were made mainly in 1875 and 1876; later dates were struck in small numbers, mainly as proofs for collectors. Congress ended the denomination in 1878. Its failure is often cited as a lesson that new coin values must be clearly distinct from existing ones to win acceptance.
Trade Dollar
The trade dollar was a silver dollar coin authorised by the Coinage Act of 1873 and struck for circulation from 1873 to 1878, with proof-only issues for some years after. It was designed for trade with China and East Asia, where merchants valued silver coins by weight and fineness and the Mexican silver dollar dominated. To compete, the trade dollar contained slightly more silver than the standard US silver dollar, and Chinese merchants often stamped such coins with small punch marks, called chop marks, after testing them.
Although intended for export, many trade dollars circulated within the United States as silver prices fell. Their status as legal tender was limited from the start and then removed by Congress in 1876, which left holders with coins worth only their melt value. The coin became caught up in the political fight over silver, and Congress later passed a law in 1887 allowing trade dollars to be redeemed.
How the four compare
| Coin | Metal | Years issued | Main reason it ended |
|---|---|---|---|
| Half dime | Silver | 1790s–1873 | Replaced by the copper-nickel five-cent coin |
| Two-cent piece | Bronze | 1864–1873 | Civil War coin shortage ended |
| Twenty-cent piece | Silver | 1875–1878 | Confused with the quarter |
| Trade dollar | Silver | 1873–1885 (proofs from 1879) | Loss of legal tender status and falling silver prices |
Silver issues among these coins were made at Philadelphia and at branch mints described under United States Mint facilities, and their metal content is discussed under coin metals and alloys.
Ref 1150000114