Normal, inferior and substitute goods are categories economists use to describe how the demand for a good responds to changes in buyers' incomes and in the prices of other goods. A normal good is bought more when income rises and an inferior good less. A substitute is a good that can take another's place, so the two compete for the same spending; the opposite relationship, where goods are used together, is covered under complementary goods.
These classifications shift the demand curve rather than moving along it, and they are measured with elasticities: income elasticity of demand for normal and inferior goods, and cross-price elasticity of demand for substitutes. They are not fixed properties of goods. Whether a good is normal or inferior depends on the buyer, the income range and the place, so the same item can be normal for a low-income household and inferior for a wealthier one. Businesses and banks use these ideas when forecasting how sales of products, including financial services, will respond to economic cycles.
Normal Good
A normal good is one whose demand rises when buyers' incomes rise, other things being equal. Most goods are normal: restaurant meals, clothing, travel and housing space all tend to increase with income. Formally, a normal good has a positive income elasticity of demand:
where is the percentage change in quantity demanded and the percentage change in income. If incomes rise by 10 per cent and spending on restaurant meals rises by 15 per cent, the income elasticity is . Normal goods with an income elasticity above 1, whose share of the budget grows as income grows, are called luxuries, and some are linked to conspicuous consumption; those with an elasticity between 0 and 1, such as basic food, are necessities.
Inferior Good
An inferior good is one whose demand falls as income rises, because buyers switch to more desirable alternatives once they can afford them. It has a negative income elasticity of demand. Commonly cited examples include cheap staple foods, store-brand products, instant noodles and long-distance bus travel, which people tend to replace with better-quality food or with car or air travel as they become richer.
For example, if incomes rise by 5 per cent and purchases of bus tickets fall by 2 per cent, the income elasticity is . "Inferior" is a technical term describing this income response and says nothing about quality. A rare extreme case is the Giffen good, an inferior good so important in a poor household's budget that a rise in its price leads people to buy more of it, contradicting the usual law of demand.
Income Effect
The income effect is the change in quantity demanded that results from a price change altering a buyer's real income, or purchasing power. When the price of a good falls, a buyer with the same money income can afford more of everything, and that extra purchasing power changes demand for the good in the same way as a rise in income would.
The total effect of a price change is split into the income effect and the substitution effect, which reflects the change in relative prices alone and always moves demand away from the good that has become dearer. For a normal good the two effects point the same way: a price fall raises demand through both. For an inferior good they point in opposite directions, because the extra real income reduces demand. Only when the income effect outweighs the substitution effect does a Giffen good result. The decomposition is developed in indifference curve analysis and is associated with Eugen Slutsky and John Hicks.
Substitute Good
A substitute good is one that can be used in place of another to satisfy the same want, a concept rooted in utility and preferences in consumer theory, such as tea and coffee, butter and margarine, or two brands of smartphone. When the price of one rises, buyers shift towards the other, so demand for the substitute increases. Substitutes therefore have a positive cross-price elasticity of demand:
where is the quantity of good X demanded and the price of good Y. If the price of coffee rises by 20 per cent and sales of tea rise by 6 per cent, the cross-price elasticity is . Perfect substitutes, such as identical units of a commodity from different sellers, are fully interchangeable; close substitutes are similar but not identical. Competition authorities such as the UK's Competition and Markets Authority look at substitution when defining a market.
How the categories compare
| Category | Key elasticity | Sign | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Normal good (necessity) | Income | Between 0 and 1 | Basic groceries |
| Normal good (luxury) | Income | Greater than 1 | Foreign holidays |
| Inferior good | Income | Negative | Long-distance bus travel |
| Substitute good | Cross-price | Positive | Tea and coffee |
| Complementary good | Cross-price | Negative | Printers and ink |
Ref 1100001719