Negative gearing is an investment situation, most closely associated with Australia, in which the income from an asset bought with borrowed money is less than the interest and other deductible costs of holding it. Under Australian tax law, the resulting net loss can be deducted from the investor's other assessable income, such as wages, which reduces the income tax payable. The investor accepts a cash shortfall each year in the expectation that the asset will rise in value.
The term comes from gearing, the use of debt to fund an investment. It is applied most often to residential investment property but also to shares bought with a margin loan. The opposite case, where income exceeds costs, is called positive gearing; where they roughly match, the investment is neutrally geared. Negative gearing is not a special concession written into law. It follows from the general rule that expenses incurred in earning assessable income are deductible, combined with the absence of rules that quarantine such losses, and it is administered by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO).
How negative gearing works
An investor borrows to buy an income-producing asset. For a rental property, deductible costs typically include loan interest, council rates, insurance, repairs, property management fees, strata levies and depreciation on the building and fittings. The principal portion of loan repayments is not deductible, which is one reason investors often choose an interest-only mortgage. The net rental result for the year is:
- is the rental income received in the year.
- is the interest paid on money borrowed to buy the property.
- is the other deductible holding costs, including depreciation.
A negative result is a net loss that reduces taxable income. The tax saving is approximately the loss multiplied by the investor's marginal tax rate:
Here is the net loss and is the marginal rate, written as a decimal.
Worked example
Suppose a property earns $26,000 in rent over a year. Interest on the loan is $30,000 and other deductible costs come to $6,000. The net rental result is , a loss of $10,000. If the owner's marginal rate is assumed to be 37 percent, the loss reduces tax by , or $3,700. The owner still bears an after-tax shortfall of $6,300 for the year. Part of the $6,000 in costs may be depreciation, which is a non-cash deduction, so the actual cash shortfall can be smaller than the tax loss suggests.
The strategy makes economic sense only if the expected gain in the asset's value, after tax, exceeds the accumulated after-tax shortfalls. For individuals, a capital gain on an asset held for at least 12 months is generally eligible for a 50 percent discount under capital gains tax rules introduced in 1999. Losses are therefore deducted at the full marginal rate while eventual gains are taxed on only half their amount, an asymmetry central to the policy debate. Rates and thresholds change, so any calculation uses the rates of the relevant year.
Risks
- Price risk. If the property does not appreciate, or falls in value, the investor has absorbed years of losses without a matching gain.
- Interest rate risk. Rises in the cash rate increase interest costs and the annual shortfall, which the investor must fund from other income.
- Income risk. Vacancies, rent falls or a loss of employment income can make the shortfall hard to carry, and a lower income also reduces the value of the deduction.
- Concentration and leverage. A geared investment magnifies both gains and losses, and a single property concentrates risk in one asset.
History and policy debate
The federal government quarantined negative gearing losses on property from July 1985, allowing them to be offset only against later property income, but reversed the change in 1987. In the 2016 and 2019 federal elections, the Labor opposition proposed limiting negative gearing to newly built housing and halving the capital gains discount, and lost both elections. Supporters argue that the arrangement treats investment expenses consistently with other businesses and encourages the supply of rental housing. Critics argue that, combined with the capital gains discount, it favours higher-income investors, adds to demand for existing homes and reduces tax revenue. Prudential policy has also played a role: from late 2014 the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) asked banks to limit annual growth in investor lending to 10 percent, a measure later removed.
External links
Ref 1010001484