Merger arbitrage, also called risk arbitrage, is an investment strategy that seeks to profit from announced mergers and acquisitions. After a takeover is announced, the target company’s shares usually trade below the offer price, because the deal may fail or take time to complete. A merger arbitrageur buys the target’s shares and, if the offer is paid in the acquirer’s shares, sells the acquirer short. The investor earns the difference, known as the deal spread, if the transaction closes on the announced terms.
Merger arbitrage is the best-known event-driven strategy and is practised by hedge funds, bank trading desks and specialist funds. Despite its name it is not riskless arbitrage: the return is compensation for bearing the risk that the deal is blocked, renegotiated or abandoned.
Cash deals and stock deals
In a cash deal, the acquirer offers a fixed amount of money per target share. The arbitrageur simply buys the target. If the deal completes, the shares are exchanged for cash at the offer price.
In a stock-for-stock merger, each target share is exchanged for a fixed number of acquirer shares. The arbitrageur buys the target and shorts the acquirer in proportion to the exchange ratio. This locks in the spread regardless of how the acquirer’s share price moves, because a fall in the acquirer’s price reduces the value of the shares to be received but produces an equal gain on the short. Mixed cash-and-stock deals are hedged in part.
Calculating the spread
For a cash offer, the gross spread and annualised return are:
- is the cash offer per target share.
- is the target’s current share price.
- is the expected number of days until the deal closes.
Suppose an acquirer offers $50.00 per share in cash and the target trades at $48.00, with completion expected in 120 days. The spread is , or about 4.17 per cent. Annualised, this is approximately per cent, before costs, financing and any dividends. If the deal fails and the target’s price falls back to, say, $38.00, the loss is , or about 20.8 per cent. The trade risks roughly five times what it stands to gain.
The market price implies a probability of completion. A simple estimate uses the offer price, the current price and the expected price if the deal fails:
With the numbers above, . The market is pricing roughly an 83 per cent chance that the deal closes. Arbitrageurs compare this with their own assessment. If they believe the true probability is higher, the spread looks attractive; if lower, they may avoid the deal or, in some cases, bet against completion by shorting the target.
A stock deal is handled in the same way but the offer value moves with the acquirer’s share price. If each target share will receive 0.5 acquirer shares and the acquirer trades at $90.00, the offer is worth $45.00. An arbitrageur who buys 1,000 target shares at $43.00 and shorts 500 acquirer shares at $90.00 has locked in a spread of $2.00 per target share, or $2,000 in total, before costs, whatever happens to the acquirer’s price before completion.
Risks
- Regulatory risk. Competition authorities may block a deal or demand remedies. Cross-border deals may also need foreign-investment, banking or sector approvals. See antitrust.
- Financing risk. The acquirer may fail to raise the debt it needs, particularly in a leveraged buyout.
- Shareholder and board risk. Shareholders may vote the deal down or a rival bid may disrupt it.
- Material adverse change. The acquirer may try to walk away if the target’s business deteriorates.
- Timing risk. Long reviews reduce the annualised return even if the deal completes.
A competing bid works in the arbitrageur’s favour, raising the target’s price above the original offer. Some deals contain collars, break fees or contingent value rights that change the payoff and must be modelled separately.
In practice
Merger arbitrage managers hold many deals at once to diversify deal-specific risk and analyse each one in detail, often with legal and regulatory advisers. Returns tend to be modest and steady, with low correlation to equity markets in normal conditions, but deal failures cluster in market crises, when financing dries up and acquirers reconsider. The strategy’s activity also helps target shareholders, who can sell to arbitrageurs at close to the offer price rather than wait for completion. Large arbitrage positions can influence shareholder votes on takeover offers, and short positions on acquirers require stock borrowing through a prime broker, as with other short selling.