Mastercard merchant and dispute programs are the schemes, rules and services through which the Mastercard network monitors the behaviour of merchants and handles disagreements between cardholders and merchants. They are run through Merchant Acquirer banks, which carry the contractual relationship with the merchant and are charged by the network if a merchant breaches the standards. Some programs target merchants whose chargebacks or fraud are unusually high, others standardise how a disputed transaction moves between issuer and acquirer, and others exchange information to prevent unnecessary disputes or to warn acquirers about merchants dismissed by other banks.
The programs follow the general logic of Card Network Rules: set measurable thresholds, notify the acquirer, require a remediation plan, and charge fees or other penalties if performance does not improve. Thresholds, fees and dates are revised by Mastercard from time to time, so the figures in the network's current rules, not any published summary, govern. The equivalent programs of its main competitor are covered under Visa Dispute and Monitoring Programs.
Mastercard Excessive Chargeback Merchant Program (ECM)
The Excessive Chargeback Merchant program identifies merchants whose chargebacks are too high, measured by the ratio of chargebacks to transactions in a month together with a minimum number of chargebacks. A merchant that passes the first threshold is placed in a monitoring tier, and one that passes a higher threshold is placed in a high-excessive tier, each with escalating fees assessed against the acquirer, which usually passes them on. The merchant is required to take action, such as improving descriptors and customer service, reviewing fraud screening and addressing the cause of the disputes. Continued failure can lead to termination of the merchant account and a listing on the Terminated Merchant File described below. The measure is related to the general Chargeback Ratio and to Chargeback Prevention. Threshold values change, so any number quoted elsewhere should be treated as an example.
Mastercard Excessive Fraud Merchant Program (EFM)
The Excessive Fraud Merchant program monitors merchants whose fraud, measured as a share of sales and as a total amount, exceeds set levels. Fraud is counted from reports made by card issuers, who record fraudulent transactions in a Mastercard fraud reporting system, so the merchant's figure depends on how promptly issuers report. A merchant identified under the program must produce a plan to reduce fraud and may be asked to use tools such as stronger authentication, address checks, device screening or Mastercard Identity Check (SecureCode). Fines and other measures can follow if the numbers do not improve. Merchants selling digital goods and operating Card Not Present (CNP) are the most exposed, and the program complements work on Card Fraud generally. The exact fees are not stated here, since they change.
Mastercard Dispute Resolution Initiative (MDR)
The Mastercard Dispute Resolution Initiative was a redesign of the network's dispute handling announced in 2018, with the aim of settling more disputes early and reducing the number that reach a formal chargeback. It reorganised the process into defined stages in a single claim flow, encouraged issuers and acquirers to exchange information before a dispute is lodged, and tightened the evidence needed at each step. For merchants, the practical effect is that responses, such as a clear Chargeback Representment, must be supported by transaction data, and that unresolved cases can be escalated through Pre-Arbitration and arbitration at the network. The details of reason codes, time limits and stages are set out in the network's rules and have been revised several times since the first introduction. A general overview is under Chargeback Lifecycle.
Mastercard First-Party Trust Program
The First-Party Trust Program is a Mastercard initiative that lets participating merchants share details of genuine purchases with issuers so that disputes by customers who did make the purchase can be spotted earlier. The target is first-party fraud, also called Friendly Fraud, in which a cardholder claims not to have authorised or received a purchase that was in fact made. The data shared typically links the order to the customer, for example account history, delivery details or digital identifiers, and the issuer can use it to decide whether to handle a dispute as a bank error, fraud or a claim to be resolved with the merchant. The aim is fewer unjustified disputes and better outcomes for merchants. Details of participation and data fields are set by Mastercard and its partners, and they are updated over time.
Consumer Clarity
Consumer Clarity is a Mastercard service developed with Ethoca, a Mastercard company, that places clearer information about a card transaction inside the cardholder's banking app, for instance the merchant's recognisable name, logo, location and order details. Many disputes start because a customer does not recognise a statement entry, and a clear description lets the person identify the purchase without contacting the bank. The service sits beside the Ethoca Alert product, which notifies merchants of a confirmed fraud or a dispute so they can refund before it becomes a chargeback. Together they reduce the volume of chargebacks and the cost of handling them, and so support a merchant's Chargeback Ratio and the bank's service costs. Participation is arranged through issuers and merchants working with the network.
Terminated Merchant File (MATCH List)
The Terminated Merchant File, known in the Mastercard system as MATCH (Member Alert to Control High-risk Merchants), is a database in which an acquirer must list a merchant whose account it closes for specified reasons. Listed reasons include excessive chargebacks, excessive fraud, laundering of transactions, non-compliance with data security standards (see Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS)), and collusion with a fraudster. An acquirer considering a new merchant is expected to check the file, and a listing typically lasts for five years. Because acquirers are wary of listed merchants, a listing makes it hard to obtain a new Merchant Account, and such merchants often turn to a High-Risk Acquirer. A merchant can dispute an inaccurate entry through the bank that listed it.
How the programs compare
| Program | Trigger or purpose | Main consequence |
|---|---|---|
| ECM | High chargeback ratio and count | Tiered fees, remediation, possible termination |
| EFM | High fraud-to-sales ratio and amount | Fines, fraud reduction plan |
| MDR | Redesigned dispute flow | Staged claims with evidence exchange |
| First-Party Trust | Shared purchase data | Fewer unjustified disputes |
| Consumer Clarity | Clearer transaction details in banking apps | Fewer confusion-driven disputes |
| MATCH | Merchant closed for cause | Hard to obtain a new account |
Ref 1040000327