A managing general agent (MGA) is a specialist insurance intermediary that has been given authority by one or more insurers to perform tasks normally done by the insurer itself: assessing risks, setting prices, binding cover, issuing policies and, in many cases, handling claims. The MGA does not carry the risk on its own balance sheet. The insurer that grants the authority, often called the capacity provider or carrier, bears the losses and holds the regulatory capital, while the MGA supplies underwriting expertise, distribution and administration.
MGAs sit between retail brokers and insurers in the distribution chain. They usually focus on niches where specialist knowledge matters, such as cyber, marine, professional liability, high-value homes or particular trades. The arrangement is a form of delegated underwriting authority. At Lloyd’s of London an equivalent firm is called a coverholder, and in the United States some are described as programme administrators. MGAs are regulated as intermediaries rather than as insurers, but the insurers that appoint them stay responsible for the business written in their name.
How an MGA works
The relationship rests on a written contract, often a binding authority agreement or an insurer capacity agreement. It sets the classes of business, territories, maximum limits per risk, premium income limits, rating guidelines and referral rules. Within those boundaries the MGA can quote and bind without asking the insurer; risks outside its authority limit must be referred. Once cover is bound the MGA issues the policy or certificate, collects premiums, often holds them in a premium trust account, and reports each risk to the insurer through bordereaux.
Many MGAs also have claims authority, allowing them to settle claims up to a set amount, or they appoint a third-party administrator. Larger claims are handled by the insurer. Brokers place business with the MGA much as they would with an insurer, and policyholders may not realise that an MGA is involved at all.
How MGAs earn money
MGAs are mainly paid by commission on the premiums they write, from which they pay the retail broker’s commission and their own costs. Commission may be flat or follow a sliding scale linked to the loss ratio, so the MGA earns more when it underwrites well. Many agreements also pay a profit commission once the book’s results are known, and some MGAs charge policy fees. Because income depends on premium volume while losses fall on the carrier, capacity providers watch closely for MGAs that grow quickly at the expense of underwriting quality.
Sources of capacity
- Insurance companies. A single carrier, or a panel of carriers each taking a share, provides capacity directly.
- Lloyd’s syndicates. Managing agents grant binding authorities to approved coverholders around the world.
- Fronted capacity. A licensed insurer issues policies under a fronting arrangement and cedes most of the risk to reinsurers, which in effect become the real capacity providers.
Losing capacity is the main business risk for an MGA, since it cannot renew policies without a carrier. Multi-year agreements, several carriers and a record of profitable underwriting all reduce that risk.
Regulation and oversight
In the United States, MGAs are licensed by state insurance departments, and many states have adopted laws based on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners model act on managing general agents, which requires written contracts with set minimum terms and regular review of the MGA by the insurer. In the United Kingdom, MGAs that arrange or bind insurance are authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority, either directly or as appointed representatives, and Lloyd’s coverholders must also be approved by Lloyd’s. Insurers carry out due diligence before appointment, monitor bordereaux, check premium remittances and run a periodic coverholder audit covering underwriting, claims and conduct. UK regulators have repeatedly reminded insurers that delegating authority does not delegate responsibility for customer outcomes.
Growth and insurtech
The MGA model has grown strongly since the 2010s. Experienced underwriters can launch an MGA with relatively little capital, and capacity providers gain access to specialist books without building their own teams. Many insurtech firms are also MGAs: they design digital products, use data and automation to price and sell cover, and rely on traditional insurers and reinsurers for the balance sheet. Some later obtain their own insurance licence to keep more of the economics, while others remain asset-light. Critics point to the risk that some insurers rely heavily on delegated business they do not control directly, and to cases where rapid MGA growth has been followed by poor loss experience. Reinsurers and rating agencies therefore pay close attention to how carriers select and supervise their MGAs.
External links
Ref 1170000168