A Joint Supervisory Team (JST) is the group of supervisors responsible for the day-to-day supervision of a single significant bank or banking group under the Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM). Each significant institution supervised directly by the ECB has its own team, made up of ECB staff and staff from the national competent authorities (NCAs) of the countries where the group has banks, branches or other relevant entities. The teams have been at work since the ECB took over direct supervision of the largest banks in the euro area on 4 November 2014.
JSTs are the main working unit of European banking supervision. They gather information, assess risks and prepare most of the supervisory decisions addressed to a bank, but they do not take those decisions themselves: formal decisions are proposed by the Supervisory Board and adopted by the Governing Council. Each team is led by a coordinator at the ECB. Smaller banks, known as less significant institutions, do not have JSTs and remain under the direct supervision of their national authority, with the ECB overseeing the system as a whole.
Legal basis and set-up
The JST model rests on two acts. The SSM Regulation of 2013 conferred specific supervisory tasks on the ECB and required it to carry them out together with national authorities. The SSM Framework Regulation of 2014 then set out how that cooperation works in practice, including the requirement for a joint supervisory team for each significant supervised entity or group. The ECB is responsible for setting up each team and deciding its composition, while the national authorities involved nominate their own staff to it.
The first teams were formed during 2014, while the ECB was preparing to take over supervision. Much of their early knowledge of the banks came from the comprehensive assessment, the balance-sheet review and stress test carried out before the SSM started.
Composition of a team
A JST combines ECB supervisors with national supervisors, so that a group-wide view of the bank is joined with local knowledge of national law, markets and language. The size of a team depends on the size, complexity, business model and risk profile of the bank. A team for a large cross-border group may have dozens of members based in several countries, while a team for a smaller domestic institution is much leaner. Within a team, members usually cover particular risk areas such as credit, market, liquidity, governance and business model risk. Team members plan their work, store documents and track findings in IMAS, the information management system shared by the ECB and the national authorities.
The team is headed by an ECB staff member, the JST coordinator, who plans and directs its work and is the main contact for the bank's management. Each participating national authority appoints a sub-coordinator to organise its staff's contribution. The teams draw on specialist divisions of ECB Banking Supervision for methodology, risk analysis and policy, which helps to keep the treatment of banks consistent across countries. The Joint Supervisory Team Coordinator (JSTC) also oversees the bank's annual SREP and signs off the team's proposals before they move up the ECB's decision-making chain.
What a JST does
The work of a team covers the whole supervisory cycle for its bank:
- Risk assessment. The team runs the annual Supervisory Review and Evaluation Process (SREP), assessing the bank's business model, internal governance, capital and liquidity, and proposes its Pillar 2 requirement and guidance.
- Planning. It sets out the year's activities in the Supervisory Examination Programme (SEP), including requests for on-site inspections and reviews of internal models.
- Ongoing review. It analyses supervisory reporting, the bank's internal capital and liquidity assessment, its recovery plan and its progress on earlier findings.
- Authorisations and approvals. It prepares draft decisions on matters such as fit and proper assessments of board members, capital actions and the use of internal models.
- Dialogue. It holds regular meetings with the bank's senior management, board and control functions, and explains supervisory priorities and concerns.
From team work to formal decisions
Most of what a JST produces feeds into the ECB's two-tier decision-making structure. The team prepares a draft decision, which is checked within ECB Banking Supervision and submitted to the Supervisory Board. Once the Supervisory Board has approved it, the draft passes to the Governing Council, which adopts it unless it objects within a set period under the non-objection procedure. Some routine matters are decided by ECB senior managers under delegated powers.
The resulting ECB supervisory decision is legally binding on the bank. A bank that disagrees can ask the Administrative Board of Review for an internal review or bring a case before the EU courts.
Relationship with inspections and wider supervision
On-site inspections and internal model investigations are usually carried out by separate inspection teams, each led by a head of mission, rather than by the JST itself. This keeps a degree of independence between the people who examine a bank on its premises and those who supervise it day to day; the JST receives the inspection report and follows up the findings with the bank. Both work to the same Joint Supervisory Standards and the SSM Supervisory Manual.
The model has been praised for bringing national and European supervisors into a single team, but it has also drawn criticism. Reviews, including one by the European Court of Auditors in 2016, pointed to uneven staffing from national authorities and a heavy reliance on them for team members. Tension can also arise between national priorities and the common European approach, which the coordinator role and the shared methodology are meant to resolve.