Interest-only securities (IO) are mortgage-backed securities that pay their holders only the interest collected on a pool of mortgage loans and none of the principal. An IO has no face amount to be repaid. Its payments are calculated on a notional amount equal to the outstanding balance of the underlying loans, and they stop when those loans have been paid off. The total an investor receives therefore depends on how long the mortgages stay outstanding.
IOs are found mainly in the US market for securities backed by home loans, both as stripped securities issued through Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae and as classes within a collateralized mortgage obligation. They are unusual among bonds because their price tends to rise when interest rates rise.
How an IO is created
A pool of mortgages produces two streams of cash each month: interest and principal, the latter made up of scheduled repayments and early repayments. In an ordinary mortgage-backed security, investors receive both. In a stripped security the two streams are separated and sold to different buyers. The IO class receives all the interest. The matching principal-only class, or PO, receives all the principal and is bought at a deep discount, much like a zero-coupon bond of uncertain maturity.
Within collateralized mortgage obligations, IO classes are also created by taking part of the coupon off another class, for example to let that class be sold at a price near par. Some carry a floating or inverse floating rate.
Cash flow and example
The interest paid to the IO holder in a given month is:
- is the interest paid in month .
- is the balance of the pool at the end of the previous month.
- is the annual interest rate passed through to the IO, as a decimal.
For a pool of 100 million dollars paying 6 percent, the first month's interest is dollars. If borrowers repay 20 million dollars during the first year, the balance falls to 80 million and the monthly payment to dollars. If they repay 50 million, the payment falls to 250,000 dollars. The coupon rate has not changed, but the investor's income has halved.
Prepayment and interest rates
The value of an IO is driven by prepayment. When market rates fall, homeowners find it worthwhile to replace their loans through refinancing. The pool shrinks faster, the future interest payments disappear, and the IO loses value. When rates rise, borrowers hold on to their cheaper loans, the pool lasts longer, and the IO pays for more months than expected.
The result is that an IO usually gains in price when rates rise and loses when they fall, the opposite of a normal bond. In technical terms it has negative duration. The effect is not unlimited: if rates rise far enough, prepayments cannot slow much further and the heavier discounting of future payments begins to dominate. The PO behaves in the reverse way, gaining when prepayments speed up because principal is returned sooner.
Uses
- Hedging bond portfolios. Because its price moves against that of ordinary fixed-rate bonds, an IO can be held as a form of hedging against rising rates.
- Hedging prepayment exposure. Investors who lose from slow prepayments, such as holders of discount mortgage securities, can offset part of that exposure with IOs.
- Taking a view on prepayments. Hedge funds and dealers trade IOs when they believe the market is overestimating or underestimating how fast loans will be repaid.
The value of mortgage servicing rights behaves much like an IO, since a servicer's fee is a slice of interest that ends when the loan is repaid. Servicers therefore face the same exposure in their ordinary business.
Risks
An agency guarantee protects the holder against borrower default, not against prepayment. An investor can receive less in total interest than the price paid for the IO, and so lose part of the money invested, even though every payment due was made on time. Sharp refinancing waves in the United States in the early 1990s and early 2000s caused heavy losses of this kind.
Valuation rests on a model of borrower behaviour, and small changes in assumed prepayment speeds move the price a great deal. This interest rate risk is one-sided and hard to hedge precisely, the market for individual IO classes can be thin, and regulators have long treated stripped mortgage securities as complex products unsuited to investors who cannot analyse them.