Initial margin segregation is the practice of keeping initial margin apart from the assets of the party that collects it, so that the party that posted it can recover it in full if the collector becomes insolvent. Initial margin covers the potential future exposure on a derivatives portfolio, the loss that could build up while a defaulter's positions are being closed out. Unlike variation margin, which settles current exposure and is usually transferred outright, initial margin is meant to sit untouched as a reserve, so the poster needs protection against the collector's own failure.
Segregation is required for regulatory initial margin on non-centrally cleared derivatives under the uncleared margin rules derived from the framework of the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) and IOSCO. It also applies, in different forms, to margin held by central counterparties for clearing members' clients. The general subject is covered under collateral segregation.
The uncleared margin rules
The BCBS-IOSCO margin framework for OTC derivatives that are not centrally cleared was finalised in 2013 and revised several times. Initial margin requirements were phased in from September 2016 to September 2022, starting with the largest dealers and extending to firms with an average aggregate notional amount above 8 billion euros or the local equivalent. Firms may agree an initial margin threshold of up to 50 million euros per consolidated group before any margin is exchanged.
The framework sets three principles for regulatory initial margin:
- Gross exchange. Each party collects initial margin from the other without netting the two amounts, so both sides are protected.
- Protection on default. Margin must be held so that it is immediately available to the collecting party if the poster defaults and is protected if the collecting party itself fails, normally through segregation at a third party under a legally robust arrangement.
- Restricted reuse. Collected initial margin should not be rehypothecated, re-pledged or reused, apart from a narrow, conditional exception that in practice is rarely used.
Gross exchange has a large liquidity effect. If a bank calculates that it needs 30 million from a fund and the fund needs 25 million from the bank, each posts its full amount, so 55 million of collateral is locked up, rather than a net 5 million moving one way. That is why regulatory initial margin is usually calculated with a risk-sensitive initial margin model, such as the industry standard model, rather than the more conservative standardised schedule.
How segregated initial margin is held
Regulatory initial margin is normally held in accounts at an independent custodian bank or securities depository, in the name of the poster or the custodian, with a security interest granted to the collector. Two models are common:
- Third-party custody. The poster delivers specific securities into a segregated account at a custodian, and an account control agreement lets the collector take control on default.
- Tri-party custody. An agent selects securities from the poster's inventory against an eligibility schedule, values them and handles substitutions, using tri-party collateral management services offered by global custodians and international depositories.
Cash is an awkward form of segregated initial margin, because cash held at a custodian bank becomes a deposit and so an exposure to that bank. Most regulatory initial margin is therefore posted in government bonds or other securities, or cash is placed in money market fund units held in custody. Documentation includes an initial margin credit support annex or deed and the custodian's control or security agreements, typically on forms published by the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA).
Segregation in cleared markets
Central counterparties collect initial margin from their clearing members, and members collect margin from clients. A CCP's own initial margin is not segregated from the CCP in the same way, since the CCP is the collector, but clients' margin is protected through client account structures. In the EU, CCPs and clearing members must offer a choice between omnibus and individual client segregation; in the United States, cleared swaps margin is protected under a legally segregated, operationally commingled model. These arrangements make it possible to port client positions and margin to another member if the clearing member fails.
Costs and issues
Segregation makes collateral safer but more expensive. Assets held in segregated initial margin accounts cannot be used for rehypothecation, funding or other margin needs, and custodial fees, legal documentation and operational processes add cost. Firms manage the burden by optimising which assets they post, compressing portfolios to reduce exposures, and clearing more trades centrally. Practical problems include delays in setting up custody accounts before a firm comes into scope, disputes over model outputs, and reconciliation of segregated balances between the parties and the custodian.