The ICC International Court of Arbitration is the arbitration body of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC), based in Paris. Despite its name, it does not decide disputes itself. It administers arbitration cases conducted under the ICC Arbitration Rules, appointing or confirming arbitrators, setting their fees, overseeing the timetable and reviewing draft awards before they are issued. It is one of the most widely used institutions for international commercial disputes.
The Court was founded in 1923, a few years after the ICC itself. Parties choose it by writing an ICC arbitration clause into their contracts, which is common in construction, energy, trade, banking and cross-border investment. ICC arbitration sits alongside other forms of alternative dispute resolution offered by the ICC, such as mediation and expert determination, which are run by a separate ICC centre.
History and structure
The Court was set up to give businesses from different countries a neutral forum in which to resolve disputes without going to the national courts of either side. Over the following century it grew from a small body handling a few cases into an institution receiving several hundred new cases a year, involving parties from well over a hundred countries. Its members are lawyers and other practitioners from many jurisdictions, who meet in plenary sessions and smaller committees to take decisions on cases.
The Court is supported by a Secretariat in Paris that manages cases day to day. To serve users in other regions, the ICC has opened case management offices outside France, including in Hong Kong, New York and Singapore. The Court's role is administrative: the merits of each dispute are decided by the arbitral tribunal appointed for that case.
How an ICC arbitration works
A case begins when one party files a request for arbitration with the Secretariat and the other side answers. The tribunal, of one or three arbitrators, is then formed, either by the parties nominating arbitrators for the Court to confirm or by the Court appointing them directly. The tribunal and the parties draw up terms of reference that summarise the claims and issues, and agree a procedural timetable covering written submissions, document production and hearings.
A distinctive feature of ICC arbitration is the scrutiny of awards. Before a final award is signed, the tribunal must submit a draft to the Court, which may require changes to its form and draw the tribunal's attention to points of substance, without deciding the outcome. Scrutiny is designed to reduce the risk of errors that could make the award harder to enforce. Awards are binding on the parties and can be enforced in most countries under the 1958 New York Convention on the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards.
The ICC Arbitration Rules
The ICC Rules are revised from time to time to reflect changes in practice. The current version came into force on 1 January 2021. Recent revisions introduced or strengthened several features:
- Emergency arbitrator. A party needing urgent interim relief before the tribunal is formed can apply for an emergency arbitrator.
- Expedited procedure. Lower-value disputes, and others where the parties agree, can be decided by a sole arbitrator on a shortened timetable.
- Joinder and consolidation. Additional parties can be brought in and related arbitrations combined, which matters in multi-contract projects.
- Disclosure and virtual hearings. Parties must disclose third-party funders, and hearings may be held remotely.
Use in trade finance and banking
The ICC is best known in finance for its rules on trade instruments, including the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600), the Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees (URDG 758) and Incoterms. Disputes over a letter of credit or demand guarantee are often settled by expert procedures under these rules, but larger disputes over underlying supply, construction or financing contracts frequently go to ICC arbitration. Banks also accept arbitration clauses in cross-border loan and project finance agreements where enforcing a court judgment in the borrower's country would be uncertain, a problem linked to conflict of laws.
Criticism
ICC arbitration is often described as expensive and slow, since parties pay the Court's administrative fees and the arbitrators' fees on a scale linked to the amount in dispute, and complex cases can take years. Confidentiality, an advantage for businesses, is criticised by those who want more public scrutiny of disputes involving states. Compared with litigation, the limited grounds for appeal give finality but also mean that mistakes are hard to correct. Rule changes on expedited cases and transparency have been partly aimed at these concerns. Model laws developed by UNCITRAL have helped make the legal framework for such arbitration more uniform across countries.
External links
Ref 1210000585