Government procurement methods are the procedures by which public bodies buy goods, services and construction. Because the money is public, the rules aim to secure fair access for suppliers, protect against corruption and favoritism, and obtain good value. Most of the terms below come from United States federal procurement, governed by the Federal Acquisition Regulation and by statute, though the underlying ideas appear in the procurement laws of most countries and in the rules of the World Bank and the European Union.
The methods fall along a spectrum. At one end is open competition, in which any qualified supplier may bid; at the other is sole source buying, in which one supplier is chosen without competition. Between them lie the processes for evaluating offers, the arrangements suppliers make to bid together, the documents that define the work, and the public-sector test of value for money that frames the whole decision. The general subject is described under procurement, and the federal framework under federal procurement rules and roles. Defense purchases follow the same principles with added rules; see defense procurement.
Full and Open Competition
Full and open competition is the standard that all responsible sources be permitted to compete for a government contract. In the United States it is required by the Competition in Contracting Act of 1984, which contracting officers apply through the Federal Acquisition Regulation. The agency publicizes its needs, usually through a notice on a federal opportunities website, and accepts offers from any supplier that can meet the requirement, using methods such as sealed bids or requests for proposals.
The law lists limited exceptions in which competition may be restricted, including where only one responsible source can meet the need, where there is an unusual and compelling urgency, where national security requires it, where an international agreement or statute directs it, and where the public interest demands it. Competition is meant to lower prices and widen the supplier base. Its critics point to the cost and delay of the process and to the weight it puts on writing specifications that do not favor one bidder.
Sole Source Acquisition
Sole source acquisition is the purchase of goods or services from one supplier without competition. It is permitted where a supplier alone can meet the need, as with a unique capability, proprietary technology or a follow-on to work only the original supplier can do, or where an emergency leaves no time to compete. Governments in other countries have similar categories, such as direct award or single tender.
In the United States the agency must prepare a written justification, which is reviewed and approved at a level that rises with the contract value, and it must generally make the justification public. The main risk is lack of transparency: without competition the price cannot be tested against rival offers, and the supplier may gain a lasting advantage. Oversight bodies, including the Government Accountability Office, regularly examine whether sole source awards were justified, and a competing supplier can challenge an award by protest.
Source Selection
Source selection is the process by which an agency evaluates competing offers and chooses a winner. The agency states in advance the criteria it will use, such as price, technical merit, past performance and management approach, and how they are weighted. A team scores each offer, and a designated official makes the final decision, supported by a written record.
Two approaches are common. In a lowest-price technically acceptable approach, the agency picks the cheapest offer that meets minimum standards. In a best-value trade-off, it may pay more for a better technical offer if the difference justifies the extra cost. A losing bidder is usually entitled to a debriefing, and may protest the decision to the agency, to the Government Accountability Office or to a court. In other jurisdictions the same step is called tender evaluation and may select the most economically advantageous tender; see tender.
Teaming Arrangement
A teaming arrangement is an agreement in which two or more firms combine to bid for a government contract, sharing the work. Typically, one becomes the prime contractor, dealing directly with the government, and the others become subcontractors; alternatively, the firms may form a joint venture. Teaming lets small firms and specialists compete for contracts too large or varied for any one of them.
The agreement usually states each party's role, how the work and revenue are shared and that the partners will not bid with rivals on the same project. Federal rules recognize such contractor team arrangements when they are disclosed in the offer. They must not be used to restrain competition: agreements among competitors to share a market, fix prices or rig bids are unlawful under antitrust law, which is why teaming agreements are normally limited to the project in question.
Statement of Work (SOW)
A statement of work is the part of a contract that describes the work the supplier must do, the deliverables, the schedule, the standards of performance and the places and conditions of work. It is the document against which the contractor's performance is measured and, where there is a dispute, one of the first the parties and any tribunal turn to.
A statement of work that lists tasks and methods in detail gives the buyer control but places on it the risk of an incomplete specification. Many agencies therefore prefer a performance work statement, which sets out the results required and leaves the method to the contractor, or a statement of objectives, in which the supplier proposes its own approach. International organizations and aid agencies use the term "terms of reference" for a similar document. A clear statement lowers the risk of disputes over what was promised and what has to be paid.
Value for Money
Value for money is the public-sector test of whether spending delivers the best outcome for the cost. It is commonly analyzed through three elements: economy, which asks whether inputs are bought at the lowest cost for the right quality; efficiency, which asks how well inputs are turned into outputs; and effectiveness, which asks whether the outputs achieve the intended results. The idea is used in the United Kingdom and many Commonwealth countries, where public audit bodies also carry out value for money audits.
In procurement it means that the cheapest offer is not automatically the best, and that lifetime cost and quality count. The same test is used to compare ways of delivering a project, for example when a government decides whether a public-private partnership gives better value than conventional public financing. Critics note that it can be hard to measure effectiveness and that appraisals can be adjusted to favor a chosen option.
Ref 1160000329