Financed emissions are the greenhouse gas emissions of the companies, projects and households that a bank, investor or insurer finances through loans and investments, attributed to the financial institution in proportion to its share of the financing. For most financial institutions they are far larger than the emissions from their own offices and operations, and they are the main measure of a portfolio's contribution to climate change.
Under the Greenhouse Gas Protocol's corporate value chain standard, financed emissions fall within category 15, investments, of Scope 3 emissions. The Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials (PCAF), an industry initiative, publishes the methodology most institutions use, and disclosure frameworks such as the TCFD recommendations and the ISSB's climate standard IFRS S2 call for financed emissions to be reported by banks, asset managers and insurers.
The PCAF attribution method
PCAF's Global GHG Accounting and Reporting Standard for the Financial Industry, first published in 2020, sets methods for asset classes including listed equity and corporate bonds, business loans and unlisted equity, project finance, commercial real estate, mortgages and motor vehicle loans, with later additions such as sovereign debt. The general approach multiplies the emissions of each borrower or investee by an attribution factor:
- is the outstanding amount the institution has lent to or invested in company .
- is the value of the company: enterprise value including cash (EVIC) for listed companies, or total equity plus debt for private companies.
- is the company's Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions, with Scope 3 added for some sectors.
For example, a bank lends 50 million to a listed company with an EVIC of 1,000 million and annual Scope 1 and 2 emissions of 400,000 tonnes of CO2 equivalent. The attribution factor is , so the financed emissions from the loan are tonnes. EVIC is closely related to enterprise value but does not deduct cash. For project finance the denominator is the project's total equity and debt, and for mortgages it is usually the property value at origination.
Data quality
Emissions data for many borrowers, especially small businesses and households, are not reported, so institutions must estimate. PCAF assigns a data quality score from 1, the best, for verified reported emissions, to 5, the weakest, for estimates based on sector averages applied to revenue or to the amount outstanding. Institutions publish a weighted average score alongside their totals and aim to improve it over time. Estimates can change markedly as better data arrive, so year-to-year movements need careful explanation, separating real emission changes from changes in data and method.
Baselines and target setting
To set and track targets, an institution chooses a base year, measures financed emissions for that year as its baseline and sets targets for later years, often for 2030 and for net zero by 2050 in line with the Paris Agreement. Targets may be absolute, in tonnes, or intensity-based, such as emissions per unit of output in a sector (for example, kilograms of CO2 per megawatt-hour of power generated) or per million invested. Sector decarbonisation pathways from international bodies and scenario providers are used to judge ambition. Baselines may need recalculating when methods change, portfolios are bought or sold, or data improve. Institutions often present financed emissions together with portfolio carbon intensity measures, and investor groups such as the Net-Zero Asset Owner Alliance have set reporting expectations for members.
Uses and limitations
Financed emissions help institutions identify concentrations of carbon-intensive lending, prioritise client engagement, design transition finance products, set sector policies and assess transition risk. They feed into assessments of transition plan credibility by investors and supervisors. The measure has several known weaknesses:
- Market sensitivity. Because attribution uses enterprise value or equity, a rise in a company's share price lowers the institution's attributed emissions even if nothing physical has changed.
- Data gaps. Heavy reliance on estimates makes totals uncertain and comparisons between institutions difficult.
- Overlap. Companies' Scope 3 emissions overlap with other companies' Scope 1 and 2, so including Scope 3 counts some emissions more than once.
- Real-economy effect. Selling a high-emitting asset lowers reported financed emissions without reducing emissions in the world, which can reward divestment over engagement.
Because of these limits, many institutions report financed emissions alongside measures of green financing and engagement, and treat the figure as an indicator rather than a precise count of greenhouse gas emissions.
External links
Ref 1180001329