The Fed put is the belief among investors that the Federal Reserve will ease monetary policy when financial markets fall sharply, and that this limits how far asset prices can drop. The name borrows from the put option, a contract that gives its holder the right to sell an asset at a fixed price and so protects against a fall below that level. No such contract exists. The phrase describes an expectation about how the central bank behaves.
The idea first circulated as the Greenspan put, after Alan Greenspan, who chaired the Federal Reserve from 1987 to 2006. Later versions carried the names of his successors. The concept is used by strategists to explain investor risk appetite, and by critics who argue that it encourages excessive risk-taking.
The option analogy
A put option has a strike price, the level at which the protection begins. By analogy, commentators speak of the strike of the Fed put: the size of market decline that they think would prompt the central bank to cut the federal funds rate, supply liquidity or signal a change of course. The level is never announced and is inferred from past behaviour. It is thought to move with economic conditions. When inflation is low, the central bank has room to respond to market stress, and the strike is said to be close to current prices. When inflation is high, easing would conflict with the goal of price stability, and the strike is said to be far lower.
The analogy is loose in other ways. An option holder pays a premium, whereas investors pay nothing for the supposed protection. An option has a contractual payoff, whereas the central bank has discretion and has at times let markets fall a long way.
Episodes cited as examples
- October 1987. After the stock market crash of 19 October, the Federal Reserve stated that it stood ready to provide liquidity to the financial system and eased money market conditions.
- Autumn 1998. Following the Russian default and the near-collapse of the hedge fund Long-Term Capital Management, the central bank cut rates three times in quick succession although the US economy was growing.
- 2001 to 2003. Rates were cut steeply after the technology share bubble burst.
- 2008 onwards. During the 2008 financial crisis rates were cut to near zero and the first programme of quantitative easing began, giving rise to the term Bernanke put.
- Early 2019. After share prices fell sharply in late 2018, the central bank paused its rate increases, which commentators called the Powell put.
- March 2020. As markets seized up at the start of the pandemic, rates were cut to near zero and large asset purchases and emergency lending facilities were launched.
The year 2022 is cited as a counter-example. Share and bond prices fell heavily while the central bank raised rates quickly to bring down inflation, and no easing followed the decline.
Evidence
Academic work has tested whether the pattern is real. A widely cited study by Anna Cieslak and Annette Vissing-Jorgensen found that, from the mid-1990s, falls in the stock market between policy meetings were followed by cuts in the policy rate more often than other economic data would predict, and that references to the stock market in the FOMC minutes and transcripts rose after market declines. The authors concluded that policymakers reacted to share prices mainly because they expected lower prices to weaken consumer spending and investment, and not out of a wish to protect investors.
This matches the official position. Members of the Federal Open Market Committee have said repeatedly that they do not target asset prices. Their legal goals are maximum employment and stable prices. They respond to financial conditions to the extent that those conditions affect the outlook for the economy or threaten the working of the financial system.
Criticism
The main objection is moral hazard. If investors expect to be rescued from large losses, they have reason to take more risk, use more borrowed money and pay higher prices for assets than they otherwise would. Critics argue that this contributed to the build-up before the 2008 crisis and to later episodes described as a market bubble.
A second objection is asymmetry. The central bank has been quick to ease when markets fall and slow to tighten when they rise, which may push asset prices and debt levels up over time. A third concerns distribution: support for asset prices mostly benefits households that already own financial assets.
Defenders reply that a severe market collapse can cause a recession through lost wealth, tighter credit and failed institutions, and that acting to prevent this is part of sound monetary policy. In their view what looks like a put is the ordinary response of a central bank to a worsening outlook.
Similar expressions have been applied to other central banks whose leaders promised support in a crisis, and to governments seen as likely to change course when markets react badly to a policy. The opposite idea, sometimes called the Fed call, is that the central bank will tighten policy if markets rise far enough to threaten its inflation goal.