The Eurosystem Credit Assessment Framework (ECAF) is the set of procedures, rules and techniques that the Eurosystem uses to make sure that all assets it accepts as collateral meet a high standard of credit quality. Banks that borrow from the central bank, whether in the weekly main refinancing operation (MRO), in a longer-term refinancing operation or overnight through the marginal lending facility, must pledge adequate collateral. The ECAF decides whether the credit quality of an asset, or of its issuer, debtor or guarantor, is good enough for that purpose, and in which credit quality band the asset falls.
The framework is one part of the wider Eurosystem collateral framework, which is laid down in the ECB guideline on the implementation of the monetary policy framework, Guideline (EU) 2015/510, commonly called the General Documentation. Other parts of that framework define collateral eligibility by asset type, issuer, place of issue and currency, and set risk control measures such as valuation rules and haircuts. The Governing Council decides on the framework, and the national central banks apply it to their own counterparties.
The four sources of credit assessment
The Eurosystem does not rely on one kind of rating. It accepts four types of credit assessment system, each suited to different assets:
- External credit assessment institutions (ECAIs). These are credit rating agencies registered with the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) that also meet the Eurosystem's own criteria on coverage and performance. The accepted group has long included Moody's, S&P Global Ratings, Fitch Ratings and DBRS, later joined by Scope Ratings; the ECB publishes the current list. They are the main source for marketable assets such as bonds.
- In-house credit assessment systems (ICASs). Some national central banks run their own systems, mainly to assess non-financial companies whose bank loans are pledged as credit claims.
- Internal ratings-based systems. Counterparties may use the internal ratings-based (IRB) approach models that their supervisor has approved for capital purposes, once the Eurosystem has also accepted them.
- Rating tools. Some national central banks accept tools run by third-party providers that score companies from financial statements.
For credit claims, a counterparty normally selects one source and must keep using it for a minimum period, which prevents it from shopping for the most favourable assessment for each loan.
The rating scale and the minimum threshold
Because these sources use different scales, the Eurosystem maps them all onto a harmonised rating scale made up of credit quality steps. Agency ratings are mapped by grade, while internal systems are mapped by their one-year probability of default (PD). Steps 1 and 2 cover ratings from AAA down to the single-A range; step 3 covers the BBB range, the lowest band of investment grade, and corresponds to a one-year PD of up to 0.40%.
Credit quality step 3 is the general minimum for eligibility. A bond rated below BBB minus by every accepted agency is normally ineligible, and a downgrade below the threshold removes an asset from the pool. For marketable assets the Eurosystem generally uses the best available rating from an accepted agency, a so-called first-best rule, and gives an issue rating priority over issuer or guarantor ratings. Some national frameworks for additional credit claims accept loans of lower quality, under stricter conditions and with bigger haircuts.
Performance monitoring and haircuts
Each accepted system is checked through an annual performance monitoring process. The Eurosystem compares the default rate actually observed among the debtors a system has rated eligible with the rate implied by the benchmark. If a system repeatedly performs worse than expected, it may have to be recalibrated, its assessments may be mapped more strictly, or it may be excluded.
The credit quality step also feeds the Eurosystem's risk control framework. A collateral haircut depends on the asset's liquidity category, residual maturity, coupon type and credit quality step, so an asset in step 3 receives a larger haircut than an otherwise similar asset in steps 1 or 2. The Eurosystem keeps the right to reject an asset or apply extra haircuts on the basis of its own risk assessment, whatever the rating.
Criticism and adjustments
Reliance on agency ratings has drawn criticism, because a mechanical link between a downgrade and loss of eligibility can amplify stress for banks and governments. International standard setters have urged central banks and regulators to reduce mechanistic reliance on ratings, and the use of four sources and of in-house checks partly answers that concern. In practice the Governing Council has adjusted the rules at times of stress. In 2010 it suspended the minimum rating requirement for Greek government debt, and in April 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, it temporarily allowed assets that were eligible at that time to stay eligible after downgrades below the usual threshold, within limits. Such measures show that the ECAF works as a policy tool as well as a technical risk control.