Embedded value is a measure of the economic worth of a life insurance company. It adds together two things: the net assets that belong to shareholders today, and the present value of the profits that the company expects to earn in future from the policies it has already sold. It is used by insurers, analysts and investors because ordinary accounting profit gives a poor picture of a business whose contracts last for decades.
The measure excludes any value from policies the company may sell in future, so it is a conservative estimate of what the existing business is worth. It is widely reported by life insurers in Asia and has been a standard measure in Europe and South Africa, while being little used by insurers in the United States. It is calculated by actuaries on principles set by the industry, not by accounting standard-setters.
Why life insurers need a separate measure
When a life policy is sold, the insurer pays commission and set-up costs at once and must set aside prudent reserves, while the premiums and investment income that make the policy profitable arrive over many years. Under traditional accounting a fast-growing insurer can therefore report losses while creating value, and a shrinking one can report profits while running off its book. Embedded value brings the expected future profits into the present so that performance can be judged in the year the business is written.
Components and formula
The calculation is:
- is adjusted net asset value: shareholders' net assets, restated to market value and adjusted to remove items already counted elsewhere. It is related to, but not the same as, book value.
- is the value of in-force business: the present value of future after-tax profits expected to emerge from existing policies, less the cost of holding the capital that regulators require to support them.
Projecting those profits requires assumptions about mortality, illness, policy lapses, expenses, investment returns and tax, and a discount rate to bring the profits back to today.
Suppose an insurer has adjusted net assets of $4,000 million. Its actuaries project future profits from existing policies with a present value of $3,500 million, and the cost of holding required capital is $500 million. The value of in-force business is million dollars, and embedded value is million dollars. If the company's market capitalization is $8,400 million, its shares trade at times embedded value.
Several figures are derived from the same model:
- Value of new business. The present value of profits expected from policies sold during the year. It is the main gauge of whether current sales are profitable, and it is often expressed as a margin on new premiums.
- Embedded value operating profit. The change in embedded value over the year from the unwinding of the discount rate, new business and differences between actual and assumed experience, before market movements and dividends.
- Appraisal value. Embedded value plus an estimate of the value of future new business. It is used in mergers and acquisitions.
- Price to embedded value. The share price divided by embedded value per share, used for life insurers in the way the price-to-book ratio is used for banks.
Development of the standards
Embedded value reporting grew up among British insurers in the 1980s, with each company choosing its own assumptions. Traditional methods discounted profits at a single risk premium rate chosen by management and made no explicit allowance for the cost of guarantees given to policyholders. To improve consistency, the CFO Forum, a group of large European insurers, published European Embedded Value principles in 2004 and Market Consistent Embedded Value principles in 2008. The market-consistent approach values cash flows in line with prices in financial markets, typically discounting at a risk-free rate and deducting an explicit cost for options and guarantees.
Later regulatory and accounting changes overlapped with this work. The European Union's Solvency II regime, in force from 2016, requires a market-consistent balance sheet and sets the solvency capital requirement, and IFRS 17, effective from 2023, recognizes expected profit on insurance contracts gradually through an item called the contractual service margin. A number of European insurers have since reduced or ended separate embedded value reporting, while it remains a headline measure for many Asian insurers.
Limitations
Embedded value depends heavily on assumptions that outsiders cannot easily check. Small changes in assumed investment returns, lapse rates or the discount rate can move the result by a large amount, and companies using different methods are not directly comparable. For this reason insurers publish sensitivity tables, and analysts often adjust reported figures before comparing them.
The measure also leaves out the value of the company's ability to write profitable business in future, which for a growing insurer may be the larger part of its worth. It applies poorly to general insurance, where contracts are short. And because it brings forward profits that have not yet been earned in cash, a high embedded value does not guarantee the ability to pay dividends, which depends on regulatory capital and on the free cash flow actually released from the book.