A derivatives clearing organization (DCO) is a clearing house for derivatives that is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission in the United States. The term is the legal name given by the Commodity Exchange Act to an entity that stands between the two sides of futures, options on futures and swaps, guarantees their performance and settles the payments between them.
In economic terms a DCO is a central counterparty. Every US futures exchange clears through one, and since the reforms that followed the 2008 financial crisis, standardized swaps must be cleared through one as well. Well-known examples are the clearing divisions of the large Chicago and Atlanta exchange groups, and the London-based clearing house that handles most interest rate swaps, which is registered as a DCO in order to serve US customers.
What a DCO does
- Novation. When a trade is accepted for clearing, the original contract between buyer and seller is replaced by two contracts with the DCO, a process called novation. Each party's counterparty risk is now to the DCO alone.
- Netting. Because all positions face one counterparty, offsetting trades cancel and only net amounts are paid.
- Margining. The DCO collects collateral from each clearing member to cover possible losses.
- Settlement. It fixes daily settlement prices, moves gains and losses between members and oversees delivery on expiring contracts.
- Default management. If a member fails, it transfers or closes out that member's positions and absorbs any loss through a set order of resources.
Only clearing members deal with the DCO directly. Other traders clear through a member firm, which guarantees their trades and passes on the margin calls.
Margin and a worked example
Two kinds of margin are collected. Initial margin is a deposit sized to cover the loss a position might suffer over the time needed to close it out in stressed conditions. Variation margin is the daily, and often intraday, settlement of actual gains and losses under mark-to-market:
- is the number of contracts held, positive for a long position and negative for a short one.
- is the contract multiplier, the quantity covered by one contract.
- and are the settlement prices today and on the previous day.
A member long 10 crude oil contracts of 1,000 barrels each, when the settlement price falls from 80 dollars to 78 dollars, owes dollars, that is, a payment of 20,000 dollars. The DCO passes the same sum to members with short positions. Because losses are collected every day, exposure never builds up beyond roughly one day's price move, which the initial margin is designed to cover.
Resources for a default
If a member cannot pay, the DCO draws on resources in a fixed order, often called the default waterfall. First comes the defaulting member's own margin and its contribution to the guaranty fund. Next comes a slice of the DCO's own capital. After that come the guaranty fund contributions of the surviving members, and finally any further assessments the rules allow. The fund is sized by stress tests so that the DCO could withstand the failure of its largest member, or for the most important DCOs its two largest, in extreme but plausible market conditions.
Regulation
A DCO must register and must comply continuously with the statute's core principles for clearing organizations. These cover financial resources, admission of members, risk management, settlement procedures, protection of customer funds, default rules, system safeguards, reporting and governance. The Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 extended the regime to swaps and required many classes of interest rate swap and index credit default swap to be cleared. DCOs designated as systemically important are subject to stricter standards and to oversight shared with the Federal Reserve. Clearing houses based abroad may register or, in some cases, obtain an exemption if their home regulation is comparable. The rules follow the international PFMI standards.
Risks and criticism
Central clearing concentrates risk in a few institutions. A DCO whose resources proved insufficient would transmit losses to all its members at once, and its failure would disrupt entire markets, so the largest are widely regarded as too important to fail. Margin models tend to demand more collateral when markets turn volatile, which can force members and their customers to sell assets at a bad moment. Membership is concentrated among a small number of large banks, so the default of one member weakens the others who must cover it. Clearing also suits standardized contracts best, and risks in bespoke OTC derivatives remain outside it.