The debates over passive investing are a set of arguments about the side effects of the rapid growth of index funds and index-tracking ETFs since the 1990s. Supporters of passive management point to low costs and broad diversification; critics and researchers ask what happens to markets, companies and competition when a large share of shares is held by funds that buy whatever an index contains.
The arguments come from academics, regulators, competition authorities, active managers and the index managers themselves. They fall into four connected groups: broad criticism of how passive investing affects prices and governance; concern about common ownership of rival companies by a few large managers; the price effect of being added to or removed from an index; and the cost to index funds of traders who move ahead of predictable index changes. The last two are practical trading questions, while the first two touch on market structure and policy.
Criticism of Passive Investing
The oldest criticism is that index funds free-ride on price discovery. They accept market prices without researching companies, relying on active investors to set those prices. Grossman and Stiglitz argued in 1980 that perfectly efficient markets cannot exist, because no one would pay for research if prices already reflected it; some fear a market that is mostly passive would become less efficient. A second concern is that market cap weighting puts more new money into stocks that have already risen, which may feed momentum or a bubble and raise concentration in a few giant companies. Others worry about crowding and weaker oversight of company management.
Defenders reply that passive funds account for a much smaller share of trading than of assets, that mispricing creates profit for active management, and that the evidence for these harms is mixed.
Common Ownership
Common ownership describes a situation in which the same few large asset managers hold sizeable stakes in most companies in an industry, such as all the major airlines or banks. Because the three largest index managers together are among the top shareholders of most large US companies, some economists argue that they may have weaker reasons to push companies to compete hard against each other, which could soften competition in concentrated, oligopoly-like markets. A widely cited 2018 study of US airlines by Azar, Schmalz and Tecu linked common ownership to higher fares, and the idea has been discussed in antitrust policy.
Other studies dispute the method and findings, and note that index managers rarely engage with companies on pricing. A related worry is concentration of voting power. In response, large managers have expanded investment stewardship reporting and introduced voting-choice programmes that let fund investors direct their own proxy votes.
Index Inclusion Effect
The index inclusion effect is the tendency of a stock's price and trading volume to jump when it is announced as an addition to a major index, and to fall when it is to be removed. Index funds must own the new member by the date the change takes effect, so a wave of forced buying meets a limited supply of shares. Studies in the 1980s by Shleifer and by Harris and Gurel documented price rises of several per cent for additions to the S&P 500, and found that part of the gain did not reverse, which challenged the view that demand curves for stocks are flat.
Later research finds that the effect has shrunk sharply, and for S&P 500 additions has been close to zero in recent years. Explanations include better anticipation by traders, deeper markets, wider use of the closing auction on the effective date, and the fact that many companies now join from mid-cap indices that passive funds already hold. Large deletions and index reconstitution days still produce very heavy volume.
Index Front-Running
Index front-running is trading ahead of expected index changes in order to profit from the buying or selling that index funds will have to do. When an index follows published rules, such as the regular ranking of US companies for the Russell 2000 Index, other traders can forecast many additions and deletions weeks in advance. They buy likely additions and sell likely deletions, then sell to or buy from index funds at the effective date, so the funds pay higher prices for what they buy and receive less for what they sell. This is lawful and differs from front-running in the sense of a broker trading ahead of a client's order.
Estimates of the cost vary, from small amounts to a noticeable drag on returns for small-cap index funds. Managers reduce it by trading before or after the effective date and accepting some tracking error, by sampling, and by tracking indices that use buffer zones or less predictable timing to reduce turnover at each rebalancing. Several of these methods are described in index fund management techniques.
How the four debates compare
| Debate | Main concern | Who bears the cost | Common responses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Criticism of passive investing | Weaker price discovery, momentum and concentration | The market as a whole | Active investors still set prices; evidence is mixed |
| Common ownership | Softer competition and concentrated voting power | Consumers and other shareholders | Stewardship reporting and voting choice |
| Index inclusion effect | Forced buying and selling moves prices | Index funds and their investors | Effect has shrunk; trading in closing auctions |
| Index front-running | Traders profit from predictable index trades | Index funds and their investors | Flexible trade timing and buffer rules |
Ref 1180001898