Currency manipulation is deliberate action by a government or central bank to keep the value of its currency away from the level the market would set, in order to gain an advantage over trading partners. In nearly all cases the complaint is that a currency is being held down. A cheaper currency makes a country's exports less expensive abroad and imports dearer at home, which supports domestic producers at the expense of those elsewhere.
The term is as much political as economic. There is no agreed test for when ordinary exchange rate management becomes manipulation, and accusations are usually made by a country with a large trade deficit against one with a large trade surplus. The term is distinct from the rigging of foreign exchange benchmarks by traders, which is a form of market abuse by private firms.
How a currency is held down
- Intervention. The central bank sells its own currency and buys foreign currency, adding to its foreign exchange reserves. Sustained purchases in one direction are the main evidence cited in manipulation cases.
- A managed peg. The authorities fix the rate, or let it move only within limits, at a level that leaves the currency undervalued. A currency peg is not manipulation in itself, but one defended at a persistently low level may be treated as such.
- Capital controls. Restrictions on money entering the country limit demand for the currency. The use of capital controls can keep a rate low without visible intervention.
- Indirect channels. State banks, public pension funds or a sovereign fund may buy foreign assets in place of the central bank, which makes the activity harder to measure.
United States law and the Treasury report
The United States has the most formal process. A 1988 trade act requires the Treasury to report to Congress, twice a year, on the exchange rate policies of major trading partners and to consider whether any manipulates its currency. A 2015 act added three numerical tests: a large bilateral trade surplus with the United States, a material surplus on the current account balance, and persistent one-sided intervention. The thresholds have been adjusted several times. A country meeting two tests is placed on a monitoring list, and one meeting all three faces closer examination and talks.
Formal designation is rare. Several Asian economies were named between 1988 and 1994. China was designated in August 2019 and the label was removed in January 2020. Switzerland and Vietnam were named in December 2020. Designation mainly requires negotiation and carries few automatic penalties, although it has been used alongside the threat of a tariff.
International rules
The Articles of Agreement of the International Monetary Fund oblige members to avoid manipulating exchange rates in order to prevent balance of payments adjustment or to gain an unfair competitive advantage. The Fund assesses whether currencies are out of line with economic fundamentals, but it has never formally found a member in breach, partly because the rule turns on intent. The rules of the World Trade Organization do not treat an undervalued currency as a prohibited subsidy in any settled way, though the argument has often been made.
Why the charge is hard to prove
The fair value of a currency cannot be observed. Estimates based on purchasing power parity or on the balance of payments differ widely, so undervaluation is always contested. Motives are also mixed. Many countries built up reserves after the Asian crisis of 1997 as insurance against sudden capital outflows, and a small open economy may intervene to stop a disorderly rise in its currency caused by safe-haven inflows.
Domestic monetary policy blurs the line further. Lower interest rates and quantitative easing tend to weaken a currency even when adopted for domestic reasons. Emerging economies complained after 2008 that large-scale easing in advanced economies was pushing their currencies up, a dispute that was widely described as a currency war. Advanced economies replied that policy aimed at domestic inflation and employment is legitimate whatever its side effect on the exchange rate.
Economic effects
Holding a currency down acts like a subsidy to exporters and a tax on consumers, who pay more for imported goods. It can raise output and employment in traded industries for a time. The costs fall on trading partners, whose producers lose sales, and on the country itself: the central bank accumulates foreign assets that may yield little and lose value if the currency later rises, and the money created to buy them can feed inflation unless it is absorbed. Economists disagree about how much of global trade imbalances such policies explain, compared with differences in saving and investment.