Credit invisibility and alternative credit data are two sides of the same problem in US consumer lending. A large group of adults has no credit history at the nationwide credit bureaus, or too little to be scored, so mainstream lenders cannot easily assess them. Alternative credit data, drawn from records of payments that bureaus do not normally hold, is one of the main tools used to bring these consumers into the scored population.
The concepts are used by regulators, lenders, scoring firms and consumer groups working on financial inclusion. Service credit is part of the picture: rent, utility and phone bills are paid after a service is supplied, yet such accounts usually reach a credit file only when they go unpaid. Reporting their positive history is a large part of what alternative data aims to do.
Credit Invisible
A credit invisible consumer is a person who has no credit file at any of the three nationwide credit reporting agencies. Credit invisibility differs from having a thin file or an unscorable file: a thin-file consumer has a file with only a few accounts, while an unscorable consumer has a file that is too sparse or too old for standard models to produce a credit score.
In a 2015 report based on 2010 data, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) estimated that about 26 million US adults were credit invisible and roughly 19 million more had unscorable files. Credit invisibility was found to be more common among young adults, people in low-income neighbourhoods and Black and Hispanic consumers. Common ways to establish a file include a secured card, a credit-builder loan, being added as an authorised user on a family member's account and, increasingly, having rent or other bills reported.
Alternative Credit Data
Alternative credit data is information about a person's finances that is not traditionally held in a credit file but can help predict whether they will repay. Examples include rent payments, utility and phone bills, records of income and spending in bank accounts, and payment of insurance or subscription services. Data may be furnished by landlords or utilities to bureaus, or provided directly by the consumer, who permits a lender to read bank transactions through open banking or account aggregation for underwriting.
When such data is used to make credit decisions about individuals, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) generally applies to those who compile and supply it, giving consumers rights to accuracy and dispute. The Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) also applies, and regulators have warned that some data, and models built with machine learning, can produce discriminatory outcomes or decisions that are hard to explain to rejected applicants.
Service Credit
Service credit is an arrangement in which a provider supplies a service first and bills for it afterwards, so the customer is in effect borrowing until the bill is paid. Electricity, gas, water, mobile phone, internet and some insurance and gym contracts work this way. It differs from revolving credit, which offers a reusable credit limit, and from instalment loans, which are repaid in fixed amounts over a set term; there is usually no stated limit, and the amount owed depends on use each period.
Service providers have rarely reported on-time payments to the bureaus, so a long record of paying such bills often does nothing for a credit file. Unpaid service bills, however, are often passed to a debt collector and can then appear as a collection account. Providers may still check credit, or ask for a deposit, before opening an account.
Ref 1120000275