A credit guarantee scheme (CGS) is an arrangement under which a third party, the guarantor, agrees to repay a lender a set share of the loss if a borrower defaults. Schemes are aimed mainly at small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), farmers, start-ups and other borrowers that lack enough collateral or credit history to borrow on normal terms. The guarantee substitutes for missing collateral and lowers the lender's expected loss, so that it is more willing to lend.
Credit guarantee schemes are among the most widely used tools of public policy for SME finance, operating in advanced and developing economies alike. They are distinct from an individual loan guarantee given by a company owner or relative, and from trade instruments such as a bank guarantee, although the legal mechanism is similar.
How a scheme works
A lender makes a loan to an eligible borrower and registers it with the scheme, paying a guarantee fee that may be passed on to the borrower. If the borrower defaults, the lender pursues recovery and then claims the guaranteed share of the remaining loss from the scheme. The key terms are:
- Coverage ratio. The percentage of the loss, or of the outstanding loan, that the guarantor pays. Partial coverage is the norm, so the lender keeps part of the risk.
- Fees. An upfront or annual charge, often a small percentage of the guaranteed amount, intended to cover part of expected losses and costs.
- Eligibility. Rules on firm size, sector, loan purpose, loan size and term.
- Claims process. Conditions for payout, such as how long the loan must be overdue and what recovery steps the lender must take first.
The lender's own loss on a defaulted loan falls with coverage:
where is the coverage ratio. If a loan of 100,000 defaults and 40,000 is recovered, the loss is 60,000. With 70% coverage, the scheme pays 42,000 and the lender bears .
Schemes usually guarantee a multiple of their capital, since not all loans default. This leverage, or multiplier, is:
A fund with capital of 20 million and guarantees of 100 million outstanding has leverage of times.
Types of scheme
Public schemes are funded and often run by the state, through a ministry, a development bank or a dedicated agency. The guarantee programmes of the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) are a well-known example, alongside national guarantee funds in many European, Asian and Latin American countries. Mutual guarantee schemes are owned by their member firms, which contribute capital and share the risk; they are traditional in parts of continental Europe. International schemes are run or backed by multilateral development banks and donors, which may guarantee loan portfolios of local banks or microfinance institutions. Some schemes also use counter-guarantees, in which a second guarantor, such as the state or a regional fund, reinsures part of the first guarantor's exposure.
Guarantees may be issued loan by loan, after the guarantor reviews each application, or on a portfolio basis, where the lender includes any eligible loan under an agreed cap. Portfolio schemes are cheaper to run but give the guarantor less control over credit quality.
Additionality, moral hazard and design
The central policy question is additionality: whether guaranteed loans would have been made anyway. A scheme that mostly guarantees loans to firms that could already borrow uses public money without widening access. Evaluations try to compare guaranteed and similar non-guaranteed firms to estimate how much extra lending, employment or investment results.
Guarantees also create moral hazard. A lender that is fully protected has little reason to screen or monitor borrowers, and a borrower who believes the state will pay may be less careful about repaying. Partial coverage, fees linked to risk, and claims rules that require real recovery efforts are the usual safeguards. Schemes can also suffer from adverse selection if lenders route only their riskiest loans to them.
In 2015 the World Bank Group and the FIRST Initiative published Principles for Public Credit Guarantee Schemes for SMEs, covering legal and regulatory framework, corporate governance and risk management, operational framework, and monitoring and evaluation. They stress a clear mandate, independence from political interference, risk-based pricing, sound capitalisation, supervision of the guarantor and regular impact evaluation.
Role in financial inclusion and crises
Guarantee schemes are used to support lending to groups that face specific barriers, such as women-owned MSMEs, farmers and young entrepreneurs, and to help close the SME funding gap. They are often combined with credit information from a credit registry and with technical assistance to lenders. Governments have scaled them up sharply during crises, including the global financial crisis of 2008 and 2009 and the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, when state-backed guarantees with high coverage supported emergency lending to businesses.
Criticism and limits
Critics argue that badly designed schemes can become hidden subsidies, accumulate contingent liabilities for the state, and weaken credit discipline. Losses may be underestimated if claims are slow to appear, and high fees or complex claims rules can make guarantees unattractive to banks, leaving schemes underused. Others note that guarantees treat the symptom, a lack of collateral, rather than underlying problems such as weak creditor rights, poor financial information or limited lender capacity. Supporters reply that, used selectively and with risk sharing built in, guarantees are cheaper and less distorting than direct state lending or subsidised credit.
External links
Ref 1120000142