A countervailing duty (CVD) is an additional import duty imposed by an importing country to offset a subsidy that a foreign government has given to the producers or exporters of a product. Its purpose is to neutralise the price advantage that the subsidy gives the imported goods over goods made by the importing country's own industry. It is one of the main trade remedies, alongside anti-dumping duties and safeguard measures.
Countervailing duties are permitted under the rules of the World Trade Organization (WTO), specifically the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (SCM Agreement) and Article VI of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT). Each member applies them through its own national procedures. The duty is collected at the border on top of ordinary customs duty, and importers usually have to post cash deposits while an investigation is under way.
What counts as a subsidy
The SCM Agreement defines a subsidy through three tests. There must be a financial contribution by a government or public body, or a form of income or price support. That contribution must confer a benefit on the recipient, measured against what it could obtain in the market. And the subsidy must be specific, meaning it is limited to particular firms, industries or regions rather than generally available across the economy.
Financial contributions take many forms:
- Direct transfers such as grants, loans on below-market terms, equity injections and loan guarantees.
- Government revenue forgone, such as tax credits or exemptions.
- Goods or services supplied by the government at less than adequate remuneration, or purchases at inflated prices.
The agreement treats export subsidies and subsidies contingent on using domestic rather than imported goods as prohibited. Other specific subsidies are actionable, which means they can be challenged or countervailed if they cause adverse effects. Officially supported export credits that follow the OECD Arrangement on Officially Supported Export Credits have a recognised position in the agreement's list of export subsidies, which is one reason the Arrangement matters to export credit agencies.
How an investigation works
A countervailing duty case usually begins with a petition from the domestic industry, though authorities can also start one themselves. The investigating authority must establish three things: that the imports benefit from a countervailable subsidy, that the domestic industry producing a like product suffers material injury or the threat of it, and that there is a causal link between the subsidised imports and the injury. The foreign government and exporters receive questionnaires and are given a chance to defend themselves. If the subsidy is very small, or the volume of imports negligible, the case must be dropped.
In the United States, the process is split between two agencies under Title VII of the Tariff Act of 1930. The Department of Commerce, through the International Trade Administration, decides whether a countervailable subsidy exists and calculates its rate, expressed as a percentage of the value of the goods. The US International Trade Commission, an independent agency, decides whether a domestic industry is injured. Both must make affirmative findings before a countervailing duty order is issued, after which US Customs and Border Protection collects the duty. In the European Union, the European Commission runs anti-subsidy investigations on behalf of the member states.
Duties stay in place only as long as needed. The SCM Agreement provides for reviews, and a duty is normally ended after five years unless a sunset review finds that removing it would likely lead to subsidisation and injury continuing or recurring.
Countervailing duties versus anti-dumping duties
The two remedies are often filed together and use similar injury tests, but they target different behaviour. An anti-dumping duty responds to dumping, a pricing decision by a private exporter that sells abroad below its home-market price or below cost. A countervailing duty responds to an action by a government: the subsidy. In a countervailing case the foreign government itself is a party to the investigation, while an anti-dumping case concerns the companies alone.
A WTO member that objects to another member's subsidy has two routes. It can impose countervailing duties unilaterally on the subsidised imports entering its market, or it can bring a case through WTO dispute settlement to have the subsidy withdrawn. The two tracks can run in parallel, but only one form of relief can be applied to the same effect.
Effects on trade and finance
Countervailing duties raise the landed cost of the affected goods, sometimes by large margins, and can apply retroactively in some circumstances. Importers therefore treat a pending case as a pricing and credit risk: a buyer may face a large duty bill after the goods are sold. Customs authorities may require larger customs bonds from importers of goods subject to orders. Exporters sometimes respond by shifting production, a practice authorities try to catch through anti-circumvention inquiries. Critics argue that subsidy measurement is complex, that duties raise costs for downstream users, and that they can be used as disguised protection, while supporters see them as a necessary answer to state support distorting world trade. Like non-tariff barriers, they are watched closely in trade negotiations.
External links
Ref 1060000273