The Conference Board Leading Economic Index (LEI) for the United States is a composite indicator, published monthly, that combines ten data series which have historically changed direction before the economy as a whole. Its purpose is to give advance warning of turning points in the business cycle, meaning the peak before a recession and the trough before a recovery.
The index is compiled by The Conference Board, a non-profit research organization, which also publishes a coincident index and a lagging index for the United States and leading indices for other major economies. It is the best-known application of the general idea of leading indicators. Forecasters, businesses and investors use it as a summary of forward-looking evidence.
History
The approach grew out of research at the National Bureau of Economic Research in the 1930s, when Wesley Mitchell and Arthur Burns classified hundreds of statistical series by whether they turned before, with or after the general economy. Later work by Geoffrey Moore refined the lists. The US Department of Commerce began publishing composite indices in the 1960s, and responsibility passed to The Conference Board in the mid-1990s. The components have been revised several times since as the economy and the available data have changed.
Components
The index has ten components, which fall into three groups:
- Labour and production. Average weekly hours worked in manufacturing; average weekly initial claims for unemployment insurance, which enter inverted; manufacturers' new orders for consumer goods and materials; the new orders index from a survey of purchasing managers; and manufacturers' new orders for non-defence capital goods excluding aircraft.
- Housing and expectations. Building permits for new private housing, and average consumer expectations for business conditions, drawn partly from the Conference Board Consumer Confidence Index survey.
- Financial. Share prices as measured by the S&P 500; a leading credit index built from several credit market measures; and the interest rate spread between ten-year Treasury bonds and the federal funds rate, a summary of the slope of the yield curve.
Each component leads for an economic reason. Employers cut hours before they cut jobs, orders precede production, permits precede construction, and financial markets react to expected profits and monetary conditions.
How the index is calculated
Monthly changes in each component are standardized so that volatile series do not dominate, and then added. The published level is an index with a base year set to 100. Analysts usually focus on the rate of change over six months, expressed at an annual rate:
- is the annualized six-month growth rate in percent.
- is the current level of the index.
- is the level six months earlier.
If the index stood at 100.0 six months ago and is 98.0 now, the ratio is 0.98, its square is 0.9604, and the annualized rate is percent. A single monthly fall carries little information; a decline of that size sustained over half a year is treated as significant.
Interpreting signals
The Conference Board describes three tests for a recession warning, sometimes called the three Ds. Duration asks how long the decline has lasted. Depth asks how large it is. Diffusion asks how widespread it is, measured by the share of the ten components that have fallen. A warning is considered credible only when the decline is prolonged, sizeable and shared by most components.
The index is read together with its companions. The coincident index combines payroll employment, personal income excluding transfer payments, industrial production, and manufacturing and trade sales, and shows where the economy is now. The lagging index, built from series such as the duration of unemployment and business loans outstanding, confirms turns after the event and is the basis for the general notion of lagging indicators. A falling leading index alongside a rising coincident index points to slower growth ahead, not to a downturn already under way.
Track record and criticism
The index has turned down before every US recession since the series began, typically several months ahead of the peak, though the lead time has varied from a few months to well over a year. It has also given false alarms, falling noticeably in periods that were followed only by slower growth. The best-known recent case began in 2022, when the index declined for about two years, weighed down by weak manufacturing orders, low consumer expectations and an inverted yield curve, a condition discussed under yield inversion. No recession was declared, as services, employment and household spending held up.
Several criticisms follow from this record:
- Manufacturing bias. Several components measure goods production, which is now a small share of an economy dominated by services.
- Little new information. Most components are published before the index, so markets have already reacted to them, and the release rarely moves prices.
- Revisions. The index looks more accurate in hindsight than in real time, because both the data and the choice of components have been revised with knowledge of past cycles.
- No magnitude or timing. A decline does not say when a downturn will begin or how severe it will be, measured for instance by the fall in gross domestic product.
The index is therefore best regarded as one summary of forward-looking data, to be weighed alongside employment, credit conditions and policy.