What is the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act?
Definition: The main United States federal criminal law on computer intrusion, which also allows victims to sue for damage and losses.
The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) is a United States federal statute, codified at 18 U.S.C. 1030, that makes it a crime to access a computer without authorization or beyond the access granted, and to damage computers or data, or to use such access to commit fraud, extortion or theft. It was enacted in 1986 as an amendment to an earlier 1984 computer crime provision and has been expanded several times since, notably in 1994, 1996, 2001 and 2008. It is the principal federal law used against hacking, data theft and the deployment of malware.
The Act applies to a “protected computer”, which originally meant machines used by the government or by financial institutions but now includes any computer used in or affecting interstate or foreign commerce or communication. In practice that covers almost every device connected to the internet. The Act sits alongside state computer crime laws and the general federal statutes on wire fraud and identity theft, and it is one of the legal foundations for the prosecution of cybercrime in the United States.
Main offenses
Section 1030(a) lists a series of separate offenses. Those most often charged are the following.
- Obtaining information. Intentionally accessing a computer without authorization, or exceeding authorized access, and obtaining information from a financial institution, a government computer or any protected computer.
- Computer fraud. Knowingly accessing a protected computer without authorization with intent to defraud, and obtaining anything of value.
- Causing damage. Knowingly transmitting a program, code or command that intentionally damages a protected computer, as with a worm or a botnet, or intentionally accessing a computer and causing damage or loss.
- Trafficking in passwords. Knowingly and with intent to defraud selling or otherwise trafficking in passwords that allow access to a computer.
- Extortion. Threatening to damage a computer or to disclose obtained data in order to extort money, a provision relevant to ransomware.
Attempts and conspiracies to commit these offenses are also covered. The first person convicted under the Act after a trial was Robert Tappan Morris, who released an internet worm in 1988 and was convicted in 1990, a ruling upheld on appeal in 1991.
Penalties and civil claims
Penalties vary by offence and by whether the defendant has a prior conviction. Some first offenses are misdemeanors punishable by up to one year in prison, while the more serious offenses, such as intentional damage or access done for financial gain or in furtherance of another crime, are felonies that can carry several years or more, and repeat offenses are punished more heavily.
The Act also creates a civil cause of action. Under section 1030(g) a person who suffers damage or loss may sue for compensatory damages and injunctive relief, provided the conduct involves one of a short list of factors, most commonly a loss of at least $5,000 during a one-year period. Companies have used this claim against former employees, competitors and operators of scraping or intrusion tools, although the courts have limited its use against some web scraping of publicly available data.
Van Buren and the meaning of authorization
The phrase “exceeds authorized access” produced years of disagreement between courts, because it could be read to criminalize ordinary misuse of access that a person legitimately holds, such as breaking a workplace policy or a website's terms of service. In Van Buren v. United States (2021) the Supreme Court resolved the question in favor of a narrower reading. A police officer who had been given access to a license-plate database and who used it for an improper purpose, in return for money, had not exceeded authorized access, because he was entitled to use that database. The Court described the test as one of whether a person may enter particular areas of a computer system at all, a “gates-up-or-down” inquiry, not one about their motives.
Following that decision, the Department of Justice announced in May 2022 a charging policy under which good-faith security research is not to be prosecuted under the Act.
Enforcement and criticism
Cases are investigated by agencies such as the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the United States Secret Service and prosecuted by the Department of Justice. Typical targets include operators of distributed denial of service attacks, sellers of stolen credentials and those who commit credential stuffing and intrusions into payment systems.
Critics have long argued that the Act's broad wording gave prosecutors too much discretion and could chill legitimate work such as penetration testing and academic research, and that its penalties could be disproportionate to the harm caused. Supporters point out that its breadth lets it reach new forms of intrusion without constant amendment.
External links
Ref 1140000218