The Commercial Interest Reference Rate (CIRR) is the minimum fixed interest rate that a government-backed lender may charge on an export credit covered by the OECD Arrangement on Officially Supported Export Credits. Each participating country calculates a CIRR for its own currency, normally once a month, from the yield on its government bonds plus a fixed margin. An export credit agency or a bank acting with official support can then offer foreign buyers a fixed-rate loan at that rate, but not below it.
CIRRs exist to stop governments from competing on cheap interest. Without a floor, a country could win an export order for its manufacturers simply by subsidising the loan rate. Together with the rules on minimum premiums and maximum repayment terms, the CIRR is one of the main pillars of the Arrangement, the "gentlemen's agreement" negotiated among OECD members since 1978. The rates are published by the OECD and apply to official financing support, not to purely commercial loans. Some countries deliver CIRR-based loans through relending, in which a state body lends to a commercial bank so the bank can fund the export credit it has granted.
How the rate is calculated
The CIRR is built from two parts: a base rate taken from the domestic government bond market and a margin added on top. Under the long-standing method, the base rate is the yield on government bonds of a maturity matched to the length of the loan, for example a three-year, five-year or seven-year yield depending on the repayment term, and the margin is a flat 100 basis points. Under the 2023 modernisation of the Arrangement, the CIRR is no longer set by the repayment period alone: the drawdown period and the repayment profile of the transaction are also taken into account.
The basic relationship is:
- is the government bond yield for the currency and maturity bucket that matches the loan.
- is the fixed add-on set by the Arrangement for that maturity.
As a worked example, suppose the relevant five-year government bond yields 3.40% and the margin is 1.00%. The CIRR is . On a loan of 20,000,000 in that currency, the first year's interest on the full outstanding balance would be . As the loan is repaid in instalments, interest falls with the balance.
How export credit agencies use CIRR
An exporter selling capital goods, such as machinery, aircraft parts or power equipment, often needs to offer its buyer several years to pay. The buyer, or the buyer's bank, borrows under a buyer credit arrangement, and the lender is paid back on a repayment schedule after delivery. Where the official agency offers CIRR support, the buyer can lock in a fixed interest rate for the life of the loan, which protects it from rising rates.
Agencies deliver this support in two main ways:
- Direct lending. Some agencies lend their own funds at CIRR, so the agency bears the interest rate risk and funding cost itself.
- Interest make-up. A commercial bank lends at CIRR and the government agency compensates it for the gap between the fixed CIRR and the bank's floating funding cost, usually measured against a market benchmark rate. If floating rates later fall below CIRR, the bank may pay the difference back. This is a form of interest rate support.
Not every agency offers CIRR financing. Many provide only insurance or guarantees, leaving the lender to price the loan commercially, often on a floating basis.
Rules on holding and using the rate
Because export contracts take months to negotiate, the Arrangement allows a CIRR to be held for a limited period while a deal is concluded, sometimes against an extra charge. Once a loan is signed, the CIRR in force applies for its life. The rate can only be used together with the other Arrangement terms: the buyer must make a minimum down payment, the official support is limited to the financed portion of the contract, the repayment term must not exceed the permitted maximum, and premiums must not fall below the minimum premium benchmarks.
Special rules apply in sectors covered by a sector understanding, such as aircraft, ships and climate-related projects, which may set their own interest terms. Concessional finance is handled separately under the rules for tied aid.
Advantages and criticism
For buyers, a CIRR loan can be attractive when market rates are expected to rise, because the rate is fixed at a level linked to government borrowing costs. For governments, the CIRR prevents a race to the bottom in interest subsidies while still allowing official support for exports.
The system has also drawn criticism. When market rates are very low or very volatile, the fixed CIRR can be either uncompetitive or a hidden subsidy, depending on the direction of rates. Interest make-up schemes expose public budgets to swings in floating rates. Large non-participants in the Arrangement can offer their own terms, which led to the 2023 modernisation and to continuing talks on wider international rules, and agencies may respond through matching.
External links
Ref 1310000366