Home / Wiki / C / Climate Scenario Analysis

Climate Scenario Analysis

Actuarial and Risk SciencesUpdated 17 Nov 2026

Climate scenario analysis is a method for testing how a company, bank, insurer, pension fund or investment portfolio would perform under a set of plausible but different climate futures. Each scenario combines assumptions about warming, climate policy, technology and the economy, and the analysis traces how these would affect revenues, costs, asset values, credit quality and insured losses over periods that often run several decades. It is used for strategic planning, risk management, disclosure and supervisory testing.

The technique differs from a forecast. It does not predict which future will occur; it explores a range of possible outcomes to show where an organisation is vulnerable and how resilient its strategy is. It is closely related to stress testing, but climate exercises usually use longer horizons, more uncertain inputs and less precise models. Disclosure frameworks such as the recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) and the ISSB's IFRS S2 standard ask companies to explain the resilience of their strategy using climate-related scenario analysis.

01

Physical and transition risk

Climate scenarios capture two broad channels of risk. Physical risk covers damage from acute events, such as floods, storms and wildfires, and from chronic changes, such as rising sea levels, heat stress and shifting rainfall. It is the focus of physical climate risk assessment, which maps the location of assets, collateral or insured property against hazard data. Transition risk arises from the shift to a low-carbon economy: carbon pricing, regulation, new technology and changing consumer demand can cut the value of carbon-intensive assets and the creditworthiness of the firms that own them. Some analyses also consider liability risk, such as litigation over climate damage or disclosure.

The two channels move in opposite directions across scenarios. A rapid, orderly transition carries high transition risk but limits warming and therefore physical damage; a world that fails to cut emissions faces little transition risk in the short run but much larger physical losses later.

02

The NGFS scenarios

The most widely used reference set comes from the Network of Central Banks and Supervisors for Greening the Financial System (NGFS), a group of central banks and supervisors formed in 2017. Its scenarios are built with integrated assessment models that link energy systems, land use, emissions and the economy, and they are updated periodically. They are grouped into broad families:

  • Orderly scenarios, in which climate policies are introduced early and become gradually more stringent, keeping warming well below 2°C.
  • Disorderly scenarios, in which policies are delayed or uneven, forcing a sharper and more costly adjustment later.
  • Hot house world scenarios, in which only current policies are implemented and warming leads to severe physical risk.

Each scenario provides variables such as carbon prices, energy mix, sector output, GDP, interest rates and temperature paths. Firms translate these into effects on their own exposures, often supplementing them with physical hazard data from climate models and with sector-specific assumptions.

03

How analysis is carried out

A typical exercise follows a sequence. The firm selects scenarios and time horizons, identifies the sectors, regions and counterparties most exposed, and builds transmission channels from scenario variables to financial outcomes. For a bank, this may mean adjusting the probability of default of borrowers in energy-intensive sectors or the loan-to-value ratio of mortgages on flood-prone property. For an insurer, it may mean projecting catastrophe losses under higher hazard frequencies using probable maximum loss measures, and testing the investment portfolio for transition shocks. For an asset manager, it may mean estimating the change in portfolio value or the carbon intensity of holdings over time.

Results are usually expressed as ranges rather than point estimates, together with qualitative findings on business strategy, such as which sectors to lend to, which products to price differently, or how to shape a transition plan.

04

Supervisory climate exercises

Several supervisors have run system-wide exercises. The Bank of England ran its Climate Biennial Exploratory Scenario with large banks and insurers in 2021, the European Central Bank carried out a climate risk stress test of banks in 2022, and the US Federal Reserve ran a pilot climate scenario analysis with six large banks in 2023. These exercises were designed mainly to build capability and improve data rather than to set capital requirements, and they found significant gaps in counterparty emissions data and in the modelling of physical risk. In insurance, supervisors have encouraged firms to include climate scenarios in their own risk and solvency assessment.

05

Limitations

Climate scenario analysis faces well-known limits. Integrated assessment models rely on assumptions about technology costs, policy and economic damage that are deeply uncertain, and some researchers argue that standard scenarios understate the economic cost of severe warming and ignore tipping points. Long horizons sit poorly with balance sheets that turn over within a few years, and static balance sheet assumptions can make results look either too alarming or too comforting. Data on counterparties' emissions, asset locations and adaptation measures is often incomplete. For these reasons, results are generally treated as a guide to direction and relative vulnerability rather than a precise estimate of loss, and they work best alongside conventional credit risk and market risk analysis.

Last updated 17 Nov 2026