Chartering negotiation stages are the steps through which a shipowner and a charterer, usually acting through shipbrokers and often in a market centred on the Baltic Exchange, agree the hire of a ship. The negotiation is conducted by message, in a compact vocabulary developed over generations, and it ends when the parties have a binding fixture. Each term in this vocabulary has a recognised effect on whether a contract exists yet, which matters if either party later withdraws.
The sections below follow the order of a typical negotiation, from the first binding offer to the moment the ship is fixed and the date window for the cargo is settled. The key idea is that of "subjects", conditions written into an offer that must be lifted, one by one, before the fixture becomes firm. Until then a party can usually withdraw without liability, and a fixture can still fail. After the fixture the parties sign a charterparty based on a standard form, and the voyage proceeds as a voyage charter or another type.
Firm Offer
A firm offer is an offer that binds the party making it for a stated period, such as "firm until 1600 hours London time", and that can be accepted during that time without further terms being agreed. If the other side accepts within the period, a contract is formed on the terms of the offer. A firm offer differs from an indication, which carries no commitment, and from an offer made subject to conditions. If a counter-offer is made instead of acceptance, the original offer is generally treated as rejected under ordinary contract principles. Brokers therefore take care over the time limit and the person to whom the offer is addressed, and the working of offers and acceptance is part of ordinary contract law. A firm offer is usually made on a clean-terms basis, with any subjects listed in advance.
Accept/Except (A/E)
Accept/except is broker shorthand in which one party accepts the other's offer except for named points, which are then restated. A message such as "accept/except laycan" accepts every term but the date window, which is replaced by a different one. Legally the reply acts as a counter-offer, so the original offer falls away. It is a way of narrowing the field of disagreement, since all points that are not listed are treated as agreed. The negotiation then continues over the excepted terms, normally leading to either a revised firm offer or a fixture on subjects. A/E replies occur before subjects are lifted and are often repeated several times in a busy market.
Subject Free
Subject free is wording that describes an offer or fixture on which no conditions remain outstanding, so that the party giving it is bound without further steps. In market usage it is contrasted with offers made on subjects. The meaning is closely tied to a related protection, "subject open" or "subject unfixed", which is wording by which an owner makes an offer on the condition that the ship has not been committed elsewhere in the meantime. Such wording lets the owner withdraw if a better employment is found before the charterer accepts. Practice varies between markets, so brokers confirm in writing which meaning is intended before relying on a phrase.
Fixed on Subjects
A ship is fixed on subjects when the main terms have been agreed in principle but the contract is conditional on named subjects. Common subjects are stem, meaning confirmation that the cargo or loading slot is available, approval of the ship by the charterer, the receivers or the shippers, the supply of documents, and the approval of a company board. Subjects are lifted one at a time, typically within a stated time, and the broker reports progress to the other side. Until the last is lifted, the party entitled to the condition may be able to walk away without penalty. The risk is greatest for the owner, whose ship may be held off the market during that period. Once all are lifted the fixture is described as clean.
Subject Details
Subject details is a condition that the details of the contract remain to be agreed, such as the additional clauses added to a standard charterparty form. It is a weak subject, because the market usually treats the main terms as settled and the details as a matter of ordinary negotiation. English law does not normally enforce a bare agreement to agree, so whether a binding fixture exists depends on whether the parties intended to be bound and whether the essential terms were certain. Brokers tend to avoid the phrase where a firm fixture is intended, and they replace it with a short list of named subjects. A court asked to decide the issue looks at the wording of the messages and the way the parties acted afterwards.
Similar Substitute
Similar substitute is wording that lets an owner replace the ship named in the fixture with another that is similar. A clause may read "MV Example or similar substitute". The right is conditional. The replacement usually has to match the nominated ship in size, age, class, speed and fitness for the cargo, and the charterer may require notice and approval. The charterer is protected by the obligation that the substitute be no less suitable, and laycan stays unchanged unless the parties agree otherwise. Owners value the flexibility because ships can be delayed, while charterers prefer a named ship, particularly when the cargo or its financiers require it.
To Be Nominated (TBN)
To be nominated (TBN) is wording used when the owner has not yet named the ship that will perform the charter. The owner agrees to nominate a ship of a described type by a set time before the laycan. Nomination lets the charterer plan the cargo, arrange the berth and complete documents, which may include a letter of credit that requires the name of the carrying ship. TBN fixtures are common for contracts of affreightment and in busy markets, where owners keep flexibility. If the owner fails to nominate in time, the charterer may have a right to cancel or claim damages. The ship, once named, normally has to meet the description given in the fixture.
Fix
To fix is the broker's verb for concluding a charter after negotiation, and a fixture is the resulting contract. A ship is fixed once the main terms are agreed and, where subjects applied, they have been lifted. The brokers then circulate a recap, a written summary of all agreed terms, which each side confirms. The recap is the evidence of the deal until the full charterparty is signed, and the parties are bound by its terms in the meantime. A fixture is binding when the intention to contract is clear, the terms are complete enough to enforce, and no subject is outstanding. Standard form clauses are published by BIMCO (Baltic and International Maritime Council). After fixing, the owner nominates or confirms the ship, the charterer arranges cargo, and agents are appointed at the ports.
Laycan
Laycan is a contraction of laydays and cancelling, and it names the window in which a ship must be ready to load. The first date is the earliest on which the charterer must accept the ship, and the second is the cancelling date, after which the charterer may cancel the charter if the ship is not ready. As an example, a laycan of 10 to 15 June means the charterer need not load before 10 June, and may cancel if the ship has not arrived and tendered a Notice of Readiness (NOR) by the end of 15 June. A ship that arrives early may usually wait, and laytime does not generally start before the first laycan date unless the charterer agrees. Late arrival has costs, notably the loss of the fixture, so owners watch the date closely. How and when laytime starts after the ship arrives within the window is dealt with in Laytime Commencement Clauses.
Ref 1060000329