Capital budgeting methods and constraints are the techniques companies use to decide which long-term investment projects to fund, beyond the two standard measures of net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR). They are used by corporate finance teams, private equity investors, project lenders and public bodies whenever a set of proposals competes for a limited pool of money.
The three members of this family answer different questions. The profitability index measures value created per unit of money invested, which matters most when funds are scarce. Adjusted present value separates the value of a project's operations from the value created or destroyed by the way it is financed. Capital rationing describes the situation in which a firm cannot or will not fund every project with a positive NPV, and so must rank them. All three build on discounted cash flow analysis and form part of wider capital budgeting.
Profitability Index (PI)
The profitability index (PI), also called the benefit-cost ratio, compares the present value of a project's future cash flows with the initial investment. It is calculated as:
The PV of future cash flows is found by discounting expected inflows at the project's discount rate, and the initial investment is the upfront outlay. The decision rule is to accept a project when PI is greater than 1, which is the same as NPV being positive. For example, a project costing 100,000 whose future cash flows have a present value of 125,000 has a PI of and an NPV of 25,000. For a single project PI and NPV always agree; they can rank mutually exclusive projects differently, because PI ignores scale.
Adjusted Present Value (APV)
Adjusted present value (APV) values a project as if it were financed entirely with equity and then adds the present value of financing side effects:
The base-case NPV discounts unlevered cash flows at the unlevered cost of equity. The side effects are chiefly the interest tax shield, less items such as issuance costs and expected costs of financial distress. For example, a project with a base-case NPV of −2 million financed with 50 million of permanent debt at a 25% tax rate, with the shield discounted at the cost of debt, gains a tax shield worth million, giving an APV of 10.5 million. APV is favoured when leverage changes over time, as in a leveraged buyout (LBO), where a single weighted average cost of capital (WACC) would be misleading.
Capital Rationing
Capital rationing is the limiting of capital spending to a fixed budget, so that not every project with a positive NPV can be undertaken. Hard rationing is imposed from outside, when a firm cannot raise more debt or equity on acceptable terms. Soft rationing is self-imposed, through internal budgets, a high hurdle rate or limits on management capacity. Under a single-period budget constraint, projects can be ranked by profitability index. Suppose a budget of 1 million and three independent projects: A costs 600,000 with NPV 180,000 (PI 1.30), B costs 500,000 with NPV 200,000 (PI 1.40) and C costs 400,000 with NPV 140,000 (PI 1.35). Ranking by PI selects B and C for 900,000, with total NPV of 340,000, which beats A and C (320,000). When projects are indivisible or budgets span several years, firms use linear or integer programming instead; the NPV forgone on rejected projects is the opportunity cost of the constraint.
How the three compare
| Method | Question answered | Main use |
|---|---|---|
| Profitability index | Value created per unit invested | Ranking projects when funds are limited |
| Adjusted present value | Operating value plus financing effects | Projects or deals with changing leverage |
| Capital rationing | Which projects fit the budget | Allocating a fixed capital budget |
Ref 1010001578