Build-operate-transfer (BOT) is a model for delivering public infrastructure in which a government grants a private company the right to finance and build an asset, such as a toll road, power plant, port or water treatment works, operate it for a fixed period, and then transfer it to the government or a public body. During the operating period the company earns revenue from user charges or from payments by a public purchaser, and uses that income to repay its lenders and give its shareholders a return. At the end of the term the asset passes to the public sector, usually at no or nominal cost.
BOT is one of the main forms of public-private partnership (PPP) and is usually documented in a concession agreement. The model spread from the 1980s, when governments in Asia, Latin America, the Middle East and Europe looked for ways to build infrastructure without adding to public borrowing; the name is often credited to the Turkish government of the period, which used it for power projects. It is closely tied to project finance, since most BOT projects are funded through a dedicated company whose debt is repaid from the project's own cash flows.
How a BOT project works
A BOT project typically runs through four phases. The government first selects a private partner, usually through competitive tender, and signs the concession or implementation agreement that fixes the term, service standards, tariffs and the hand-back conditions. The sponsors then set up a project special purpose vehicle, which raises equity and debt and signs the construction, operation and, where relevant, supply and sales contracts.
During construction the project company bears most of the risk of delay and cost overrun, which it usually passes to a contractor under a fixed-price, date-certain EPC contract. In the operating phase it collects revenue, maintains the asset and services its debt through a cash flow waterfall. At transfer, the asset must normally be handed back in a specified condition, and contracts often require a maintenance reserve or an inspection several years before expiry to make sure this happens.
Variants
Several related models differ mainly in who owns the asset and when:
- Build-own-operate-transfer (BOOT). The private company owns the asset during the concession period and then transfers ownership, a distinction that matters for tax, security and accounting.
- Build-own-operate (BOO). The private company keeps the asset permanently, so there is no transfer; this is common for power plants selling under a power purchase agreement.
- Build-transfer-operate (BTO). Ownership passes to the public sector on completion, and the private party then operates the asset under a lease or operating contract.
- Design-build-finance-operate (DBFO). The private partner also takes on design and is usually paid by the authority rather than by users; see design-build-finance-operate (DBFO).
Financing structure
BOT projects are usually highly leveraged, with debt often making up most of the capital and equity the remainder. Lenders may include commercial banks, export credit agencies, development finance institutions such as members of the World Bank Group, and, once the asset is operating, bond investors. The debt is sized on the forecast debt service coverage ratio and must be repaid before the concession ends, leaving a period at the end, known as the tail, in which revenue still flows but no debt remains.
Because the lenders have limited recourse to the sponsors, they rely on the contract package: the concession agreement, guaranteed offtake or availability payments where demand is uncertain, a direct agreement giving them step-in rights, and security over the project's accounts and shares. Where the purchaser is a state-owned company with weak credit, the host government may add a sovereign guarantee.
Risks and criticism
The main risks in a BOT project are construction risk, demand or traffic risk on user-paid assets, currency risk when revenue is in local currency but debt is in foreign currency, and political risk, including tariff freezes, changes in law and expropriation. How these are shared between the private partner and the government largely determines the price of the project and whether it can be financed.
Critics argue that BOT can cost more than public borrowing, because private finance is more expensive than government debt, and that guarantees and minimum revenue commitments create hidden contingent liabilities for the state. Long contracts can also be hard to adjust when needs change, and disputes over tariffs have led to renegotiation in many countries. Supporters point to faster delivery, whole-life maintenance and the transfer of construction risk to parties able to manage it.
Examples
BOT and similar concession models have been used widely for toll roads, tunnels and bridges, independent power plants, airports, ports and water and wastewater plants. The Channel Tunnel between the United Kingdom and France was built and is run by a private company under a long-term concession from the two governments, and many independent power producers in South and South-East Asia were financed on BOT or BOO terms. Comparable arrangements are found in roads in Latin America and in desalination plants in the Gulf.
External links
Ref 1010001283