A box spread is a four-part options position whose value at expiration is the same whatever happens to the price of the underlying asset. It consists of a bull call spread and a bear put spread on the same underlying, with the same two strike prices and the same expiration date. Because the payoff is fixed, buying a box is equivalent to lending money and selling a box is equivalent to borrowing it.
The position can also be described as two synthetic positions: a synthetic long in the underlying at the lower strike and a synthetic short at the higher strike. Market makers use boxes in arbitrage and to finance their books, and institutional investors use them as a substitute for short-term lending and borrowing. The box is the basis of several relationships that tie option prices together.
Construction
A long box with a lower strike and a higher strike has four legs:
- Buy a call option with strike .
- Sell a call with strike .
- Buy a put option with strike .
- Sell a put with strike .
If the underlying finishes above , the call spread is worth and the puts expire worthless. If it finishes below , the put spread is worth and the calls expire worthless. Anywhere in between, the two spreads together are still worth exactly that amount. The payoff at expiration is therefore always the difference between each strike price. A short box reverses all four legs: the seller receives a premium now and owes the fixed amount at expiration.
Pricing and the implied interest rate
Since the payoff is certain, the fair value of a box today is that payoff discounted at the risk-free rate:
where is the continuously compounded interest rate and is the time to expiration in years. Turning the relation round, the price at which a box trades reveals an interest rate. For a one-year box, using simple annual interest:
Suppose index options with strikes of 100 and 110 expire in one year, and the four legs can be bought for a net cost of 9.60. The box will pay 10 at expiration. The buyer earns percent, and the seller has in effect borrowed at the same rate. If one-year Treasury bills yielded 4 percent, the box would offer a small pick-up to the lender and a borrowing rate well below a typical broker's margin loan to the seller.
In this respect a long box behaves like a zero-coupon bond. Its market value before expiration moves with interest rates, so a holder who closes early may realize a gain or loss.
Use in arbitrage and financing
If a box can be bought for less than the discounted value of its payoff, an arbitrageur can buy it and finance the purchase at the risk-free rate for a certain profit, and the reverse if it is too expensive. Such gaps are small and brief in liquid markets, and after transaction costs they are generally available only to exchange members. The box is closely related to the conversion and its reverse, which lock option prices to the price of the underlying through put-call parity. A box is a conversion at one strike combined with a reversal at another, with the underlying cancelling out.
Outside pure arbitrage, the main use today is financing. Large investors lend cash by buying boxes on the S&P 500 index, and others sell them to borrow at rates close to those on Treasury bills. Exchange clearing removes most counterparty risk. Funds have been launched that hold box spreads as a cash-like investment.
Risks
- Early exercise. The fixed payoff is guaranteed only with a European option, which cannot be exercised before expiration. With an American-style option, a short leg that is deep in the money may be exercised early, leaving the position unbalanced. Assignment on the short legs of boxes written on individual shares has caused large losses to retail traders who believed the trade to be free of risk.
- Margin. A short box is a loan, and the broker requires margin against the amount owed. Changes in the market value of the box before expiration can lead to calls for more funds.
- Execution. Four legs mean four bid-ask spreads and four sets of fees. A box priced fairly in theory can be costly to enter and to exit unless it is traded as a single package.
- Settlement differences. Options settled by delivery of shares can leave residual positions if the underlying closes near a strike. Index options that use cash settlement avoid this.
- Tax treatment. The gain on a box is economically interest but may be taxed under the rules for options, which differ by country.
For these reasons the trade is carried out mainly in European-style, cash-settled index options, such as those listed on the Chicago Board Options Exchange.