Bond refunding is the process by which an issuer sells new bonds and uses the money to pay off bonds it already has outstanding. The new issue is the refunding issue, and the old one is the refunded issue. The usual purpose is to replace debt carrying a high interest rate with debt at a lower rate after market yields have fallen, in much the same way that a homeowner turns to refinancing a mortgage.
Refunding is common among companies and, above all, among US state and local governments. It depends on the issuer's right to redeem the old bonds early, so it is closely tied to the terms of a callable bond. The benefit to the issuer is a cost to investors, who lose a high-yielding holding and must reinvest at lower rates, an exposure known as call risk.
Reasons for refunding
- Interest savings. The most frequent motive is to reduce debt service when current rates are below the coupon on the old bonds.
- Restructuring. An issuer may wish to lengthen or shorten the repayment schedule, or to smooth out years in which large amounts fall due.
- Removing restrictions. Retiring the old bonds cancels the covenants in the old bond indenture, which may limit new borrowing or require reserves.
Current and advance refunding
The timing of the transaction relative to the call date defines two types. In a current refunding, the old bonds are redeemed within 90 days of the sale of the new bonds. The proceeds go more or less directly to the holders through a bond redemption at the call price.
In an advance refunding, the new bonds are sold more than 90 days before the old bonds can be called. The proceeds are placed in an escrow account and invested, normally in Treasury securities whose payments match the interest due on the old bonds up to the call date and the call price on that date. The old issue then becomes an advance-refunded bond, backed by the escrow instead of the issuer's own revenues, and its credit quality usually rises to the highest level. The technique is also called pre-refunding. If the escrow runs to the final maturity instead of a call date, the bonds are said to be escrowed to maturity.
Measuring the savings
Issuers judge a refunding by the present value of the reduction in debt service, net of costs:
- and are the debt service payments in period on the old and the new bonds.
- is the discount rate, usually the yield on the refunding bonds.
- is the number of periods remaining.
- is the total of the call premium and the costs of issuing the new bonds.
Suppose a city has $10 million of 6 percent bonds with ten years remaining and can issue new ten-year bonds at 4 percent. Annual interest falls from $600,000 to $400,000, a saving of $200,000 a year. Discounted at 4 percent, ten annual savings of $200,000 are worth dollars. If the call premium is 2 percent of principal, or $200,000, and issue costs are $150,000, the net present value saving is dollars, about 12.7 percent of the refunded principal.
Many governments set a minimum threshold, often present value savings of around 3 percent of the refunded amount, before a refunding is approved. A positive result does not settle the matter, since calling the bonds uses up the option to call them later at a still lower rate.
Tax rules in the United States
Because advance refunding leaves two tax-exempt issues outstanding for one project until the call date, federal law has long restricted it. The Tax Reform Act of 1986 generally allowed a governmental issue to be advance refunded only once on a tax-exempt basis. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 went further and removed the tax exemption for interest on advance refunding bonds issued after 31 December 2017. Current refundings were not affected.
Since then issuers wishing to lock in savings before the call date have used other methods. These include taxable advance refunding bonds, forward delivery bonds that are priced now and delivered within 90 days of the call date, and offers to buy back or exchange the old bonds. Rules on the yield of the escrow investments limit an issuer's ability to earn more on the escrow than it pays on the new bonds.
Effects on investors
Holders of bonds that are currently refunded receive the call price and lose the remaining coupons. Holders of advance-refunded bonds keep their bonds until the call date and benefit from the improved security, so the price usually rises to reflect the short remaining life and the Treasury-backed escrow. Investors in callable bonds allow for the likelihood of refunding by looking at the yield to the call date as well as the yield to maturity, and they demand a higher coupon than on comparable non-callable debt. A sinking fund, which retires part of an issue each year from the issuer's own resources, is a separate mechanism and is not a refunding.