A board challenge session is a meeting, or a dedicated part of one, in which the board of directors tests management's proposals before approving them. Rather than receiving a presentation and voting, non-executive directors question the assumptions, alternatives and risks behind a strategy, budget, acquisition or capital plan, and ask management to defend or revise them.
In banks and insurers, supervisors expect boards to show effective challenge of documents such as the ICAAP, recovery plans, stress test scenarios and the risk appetite statement. A common supervisory criticism is that board minutes record approval without discussion, so firms minute the questions raised, the answers given and any changes made. Good challenge sessions depend on a clear board information pack circulated early, enough time on the agenda and directors with the right skills, which a board effectiveness evaluation may review.