Home / Wiki / A / Auction Rate Security (ARS)

Auction Rate Security (ARS)

Investment and Capital MarketsUpdated 16 Nov 2026

An auction rate security (ARS) is a long-term debt instrument or preferred share whose interest or dividend rate is reset at short, regular intervals, typically every 7, 28 or 35 days, through an auction among investors. The auction also serves as the main way for holders to sell. The design let issuers borrow for decades while paying short-term rates, and let investors hold what looked like a short-term asset with a slightly higher yield than a money market fund.

The instruments were introduced in the United States in the mid-1980s. Issuers were mainly municipalities and public authorities, student loan lenders and each closed-end fund that issued auction rate preferred stock to borrow against its portfolio. The market grew to several hundred billion dollars before it broke down in February 2008, and it has not recovered.

01

How the auction works

The auction is a form of Dutch auction run by an auction agent, with orders submitted through one or more broker-dealers. Before each auction an existing holder chooses one of three instructions: to hold whatever the new rate is, to hold only if the rate is at or above a stated level, or to sell. New buyers bid by stating the lowest rate they will accept and the amount they want.

Bids are ranked from the lowest rate upward. The clearing rate is the lowest rate at which all the securities offered for sale can be placed, and it applies to every holder until the next auction. Securities change hands at par value.

Suppose an issue of 100 million has holders of 40 million who choose to hold at any rate, so 60 million is for sale. Buyers bid for 30 million at 3.00 percent, 20 million at 3.10 percent, 20 million at 3.20 percent and 10 million at 3.30 percent. The first two bids absorb 50 million, and 10 million of the third bid is needed to place the rest. The clearing rate is 3.20 percent. The bid at 3.30 percent receives nothing.

02

Failed auctions

An auction fails when there are too few bids to cover the securities offered for sale. In that case no one can sell, all holders keep their positions, and the rate is set by a formula in the offering documents, known as the maximum or penalty rate. For some issues that rate was high, which compensated holders and pushed the issuer to refinance. For others it was capped at a low level, leaving holders with a poor return and no exit.

For many years failures were rare because the broker-dealer managing an auction would bid with its own capital when demand fell short. That support was a practice, not an obligation, and many investors were not aware of the difference.

03

The 2008 collapse

During the 2008 financial crisis, losses at the bond insurers that guaranteed many issues weakened confidence, and dealers under balance-sheet pressure stopped supporting auctions. In mid-February 2008 the majority of auctions failed within days. Investors who had been told the securities were as good as cash, including individuals, companies holding them as a cash equivalent and charities, found that they could not sell.

The Securities and Exchange Commission and state regulators, led by the New York Attorney General, brought cases alleging that firms had misrepresented the liquidity risk. In settlements beginning in August 2008, large banks and brokers agreed to buy back tens of billions of dollars of the securities at par from retail customers and to pay penalties. Many issuers refinanced, although some student loan and fund issues remained outstanding for years.

04

Risks and legacy

  • Liquidity. A holder can exit only if an auction succeeds or a buyer is found privately, usually at a discount.
  • Maturity. The underlying bond is long-term or, for preferred shares, perpetual, whatever the reset interval.
  • Rate formula. The return after a failure depends on a maximum-rate clause that few buyers studied in advance.
  • Credit. Payment still depends on the issuer and on any insurer behind it, a point that a bond rating addresses only in part.

Since 2008 accounting practice has not treated the securities as cash equivalents, and new issuance has all but ceased. Municipal borrowers seeking floating rates have turned to instruments that give the holder a contractual right to sell back, supported by a bank liquidity facility, and to the floating rate note. The episode is often cited as an example of the gap between how a product behaves in normal markets and what its terms actually promise.

Last updated 16 Nov 2026