An analyst rating is a research analyst's published opinion on how a security, most often a company's stock, is expected to perform over a stated period, typically the next twelve months. It is expressed as a short label such as buy, hold or sell and normally comes with a price target and forecasts of earnings. An analyst ratings summary gathers the current opinions of all the analysts covering a security into one table.
Most widely quoted ratings come from sell-side analysts, who work for a brokerage or an investment bank and distribute research to clients. Independent research firms also publish ratings, while analysts employed by fund managers generally keep theirs private. An analyst rating on a share should not be confused with a credit rating, which is an opinion on a borrower's ability to repay debt.
Rating scales and price targets
Firms use different words for similar ideas. Common three-point scales are buy, hold and sell; overweight, equal-weight and underweight; and outperform, market perform and underperform. Some firms add strong buy and strong sell to make five points. A label may be absolute, meaning an expected return above a set threshold, or relative, meaning expected performance against a sector or index, so each firm's published definitions should be checked. Ratings are reviewed after quarterly results, and a firm may suspend a rating while it advises the company on a transaction.
The price target is the analyst's estimate of where the security will trade at the end of the period. It usually rests on fundamental analysis, for example a discounted cash flow model or a multiple such as the price-to-earnings ratio applied to forecast profit. The implied upside is:
where is the price target and is the current market price. A target of 115 on a share trading at 100 implies an upside of , or 15 percent, before dividends.
What a ratings summary shows
- Distribution. The number of analysts in each category, such as 12 buy, 6 hold and 2 sell.
- Consensus. The analyst consensus rating, an average of the opinions on a numerical scale.
- Price targets. The mean or median target, with the highest and lowest.
- Forecasts. The consensus estimate of revenue and earnings per share for coming periods.
- Recent changes. Upgrades, downgrades, new coverage and revisions to targets.
Data vendors compile these tables from broker reports, and their figures can differ according to which firms they include and how quickly they record changes.
Regulation and conflicts of interest
Sell-side research has an inherent conflict: the firm publishing a rating may also seek fees from the company for underwriting an initial public offering or advising on a merger, and analysts depend on access to management. After the collapse of the technology share boom, US regulators found that some analysts had praised companies in public while disparaging them in private. In the Global Analyst Research Settlement of 2003, ten large firms agreed to pay about 1.4 billion dollars and to separate research from investment banking.
Rules adopted by the Securities and Exchange Commission and the industry's self-regulator now require analysts to certify that reports reflect their personal views, bar pay tied to specific banking deals, and require each report to disclose the firm's relationships with the company and the share of its ratings in each category. In Europe, MiFID II changed the economics of research from 2018 by requiring fund managers to pay for it separately from trading commissions, a rule that has since been relaxed.
Evidence on usefulness
Ratings are skewed. Buy and equivalent labels greatly outnumber sells, so a hold is often read as a mild negative. Academic studies have generally found that the level of a rating says little about future returns, while changes carry more information: share prices tend to move on upgrades and downgrades and, in some studies, to keep drifting in the same direction for a time. Under the efficient market hypothesis, published opinions should be absorbed into prices quickly, leaving little for later followers.
Analysts also tend to move together, revising after results or guidance from corporate earnings reports instead of ahead of them, and price targets are often missed. Investors therefore treat ratings as one input among several, paying more attention to the reasoning and estimates in a report than to the label.