Alternative mortgage instruments are home loan structures that differ from the standard first mortgage with a fixed rate or a conventional adjustable rate. The label covers loans that sit behind another lien, loans that wrap around an existing debt, loans whose rate is reset by renegotiation, and loans in which the lender shares in the property's future value. Some were created by regulators or lenders to cope with high and volatile interest rates; others grew out of private sales between buyers and sellers.
In the United States the term gained currency around 1980, when thrift regulators allowed savings and loan associations to offer loans other than the long-term fixed-rate mortgage that had left them exposed to rising rates. The members of the family differ mainly in lien position, in who bears interest-rate risk and in how much of the home's equity the borrower keeps.
Second Mortgage
A second mortgage is a loan secured by a home that already carries a first mortgage, so the new lender's lien ranks behind the first. The two common forms are the lump-sum home equity loan and the revolving home equity line of credit (HELOC); a second loan taken at purchase to avoid a large down payment is known as a piggyback mortgage.
Lien priority drives the pricing. If the borrower defaults and the home is sold through foreclosure, the first lender is repaid in full before the second lender receives anything. Because the junior lender may recover little or nothing when prices fall, second mortgages usually carry higher rates and tighter limits on the combined loan-to-value ratio. In the United Kingdom the equivalent product is called a second charge mortgage. Taking a second mortgage leaves the first loan in place, which distinguishes it from a cash-out refinance that replaces it.
Wraparound Mortgage
A wraparound mortgage is a form of seller financing in which the seller gives the buyer a new loan for most of the price while leaving the seller's own mortgage in place. The new loan "wraps around" the old one: the buyer makes a single payment to the seller, who keeps paying the original lender and pockets the difference. It is a type of owner financing, used when buyers cannot obtain bank credit or when the existing loan has a low rate.
The seller usually charges a rate above that of the underlying loan, earning a spread on the old balance as well as interest on the equity financed. The main legal risk is the due-on-sale clause found in most modern mortgages. Federal law in the United States, the Garn-St Germain Act of 1982, generally allows lenders to enforce such clauses, so a transfer of the property can let the original lender demand full repayment. The buyer also depends on the seller continuing to pay the old loan.
Renegotiable-Rate Mortgage (RRM)
A renegotiable-rate mortgage (RRM), also called a rollover mortgage, is a long-term US home loan made as a series of short-term loans, typically three to five years each, that renew automatically at a new rate. The Federal Home Loan Bank Board authorised federally chartered savings and loan associations to offer it in 1980, as thrifts sought relief from fixed-rate portfolios funded with increasingly expensive deposits.
At each renewal the rate is reset to reflect market rates, within limits on the change per renewal and over the life of the loan, and the lender must offer to renew. The structure moves some interest rate risk from lender to borrower, though less abruptly than a loan that simply matures. The RRM was soon overshadowed by the indexed adjustable-rate mortgage, which adjusts automatically rather than by renewal. The Canadian mortgage market still works in a similar way: loans are amortised over 25 years or more, but the rate is fixed only for a term of a few years and then renewed.
A shared appreciation mortgage (SAM) is a loan in which the lender or an investor accepts a lower interest rate, or provides help with the down payment, in return for a share of any increase in the home's value. The share is paid when the home is sold, refinanced or the loan reaches a set date. A loan with a reduced rate in exchange for a one-third share of gains is a typical illustration of the trade-off.
SAMs lower the monthly cost of borrowing but transfer part of the future gain on the property, and hence part of the borrower's home equity, to the funder. If prices rise sharply, the deferred cost can far exceed the interest saved; disputes over loans sold in the United Kingdom in the late 1990s showed how contentious this can become. Related arrangements include shared-equity schemes run by governments and housing bodies, and products such as home reversion plans, in which a provider buys part of a home outright.
Comparing the instruments
| Instrument | Lien position | Main feature | Main risk to borrower |
|---|---|---|---|
| Second mortgage | Junior to first loan | Borrows against equity, first loan stays | Higher rate; two loans secured on the home |
| Wraparound mortgage | Junior to the seller's loan | One payment covers old and new debt | Due-on-sale call; seller failing to pay |
| Renegotiable-rate mortgage | First lien | Rate reset at each renewal | Higher payments after renewal |
| Shared appreciation mortgage | Usually first lien | Lower rate for share of price gains | Large deferred payment if values rise |
Ref 1030001023