Home / Wiki / M / Maker-Checker

Maker-Checker

Compliance Risk and ControlsUpdated 12 Nov 2026

Maker-checker is an internal control in which one person (the maker) prepares or enters a transaction or change, and a second, independent person (the checker) reviews and approves it before it takes effect. Banks, payment companies, fund administrators and corporate finance teams use it for payments, account changes, limit settings and other sensitive actions, so that no single person can complete them alone.

The control is a practical form of the "four-eyes principle" and of segregation of duties, a long-standing principle of internal control. It sits within a firm's wider management of operational risk and is usually enforced by software through role-based access control (RBAC), which decides who may create entries and who may approve them. In crypto custody the same idea appears as a multi-sig wallet, where more than one key must sign.

01

Maker-checker in plain terms

Think of a company cheque that needs two signatures. The bookkeeper fills in the amount and the payee, but the cheque is useless until a manager reads it and signs too. If the bookkeeper typed an extra zero, or tried to pay a friend, the second person should spot it.

Maker-checker brings that two-signature habit into computer systems. One person keys in a payment; it waits in a queue until someone else, who did not create it, opens it, compares it with the paperwork and presses "approve". Mistakes and dishonesty both become harder, because they need to slip past two people instead of one.

02

How the control works

  1. The maker creates a record, such as a wire payment, a new beneficiary, a change to a customer's address or a new credit limit.
  2. The system holds the record in a pending state and blocks the maker from approving it.
  3. The checker reviews the record against source documents or rules and approves, rejects or returns it with comments.
  4. The system logs who made, checked and released the record, and when, creating an audit trail.

High-value or high-risk actions can require more than one checker, sometimes called "maker-checker-authoriser", with approval limits tied to seniority. Many systems also stop a user from holding both roles for the same item, and require each approver to sign in separately rather than share credentials.

03

Where it is used

04

Regulatory background

Segregation of duties is a core expectation of bank supervisors. The Basel Committee's 1998 Framework for Internal Control Systems in Banking Organisations names inadequate segregation of duties as a cause of major bank losses and says conflicting duties should be split between people. Company-law and audit regimes, such as Section 404 of the US Sarbanes-Oxley Act 2002, require management to maintain and test internal controls over financial reporting, and external auditors check whether dual controls really operate. Regulators reviewing an AML program, or an independent AML review, routinely look for maker-checker evidence on alert handling and customer approvals.

05

Failures that shaped the practice

The collapse of Barings Bank in 1995 is the standard case study: a trader in Singapore controlled both the front office and the back office that settled his trades, and hid losses of about £827 million. In 2008 Société Générale lost about €4.9 billion unwinding unauthorised positions built by a trader who knew how to get around its controls. In the 2016 Bangladesh Bank theft, attackers used stolen operator credentials to send fraudulent SWIFT payment messages, showing that dual control fails if both sets of credentials can be compromised.

06

Limitations

Maker-checker is only as strong as the checking. Common weaknesses include checkers approving in bulk without reading ("rubber-stamping"), collusion between maker and checker, shared passwords, and urgent requests from apparent senior managers that pressure staff to skip review, a tactic used in authorized push payment (APP) fraud. Firms address these with approval limits, random sampling, rotation of staff, monitoring of approval times and independent audit. The control reduces, but cannot remove, the risk of fraud and error, and the cost of extra review must be weighed against the size of the losses it prevents.

Last updated 12 Nov 2026