A financial regulator is a public authority that licenses, supervises and enforces rules on financial businesses such as banks, insurers, securities firms, asset managers and payment companies. Its goals are usually to keep firms and the wider system safe, protect consumers and investors, keep markets fair and orderly, and prevent financial crime. Some regulators are government departments; most are independent agencies created by statute, and many are part of or linked to the central bank.
A regulator is an institution; the rules it applies form part of a country's financial regulatory framework. Every country has at least one, and most have several, each with its own slice of the market. A worldwide directory is kept in the list of financial regulators around the world.
Financial regulator in plain terms
A financial regulator is the referee and the licensing office rolled into one. Before a firm can take deposits, sell insurance or move money for customers, it has to show the regulator that it has enough capital, honest owners and proper systems. Once it is in the game, the regulator watches how it plays and can stop it if it breaks the rules.
The reason for the extra attention is that customers often cannot judge a bank or insurer for themselves, and a failure can spread to other firms. A regulator checks on everyone's behalf, a bit like a food-safety inspector checking restaurant kitchens the diners never see.
What financial regulators do
- Authorisation. Granting licences and charters, from a bank charter to a money transmitter license, and deciding which activities fall inside the regulatory perimeter.
- Prudential supervision. Setting and checking regulatory capital, liquidity and risk-management standards so firms can absorb losses.
- Conduct supervision. Making sure products are sold fairly, fees are disclosed and complaints are handled.
- Financial-crime controls. Checking anti-money laundering and sanctions programmes, often alongside a financial intelligence unit such as FinCEN.
- Enforcement. Investigating breaches and imposing fines, licence restrictions or bans through regulatory enforcement, which may start with a cease-and-desist notice.
Models of regulation
Countries organise their regulators in three broad ways. In the sectoral model, separate bodies cover banking, securities and insurance; the United States is the main example, with the Federal Reserve, the OCC and the FDIC for banks, the SEC and CFTC for markets, state insurance commissioners, and state agencies such as NYDFS for money transmitters, coordinated through bodies such as the CSBS. In the integrated model, one authority covers almost everything; Switzerland's FINMA and Singapore's MAS work this way. In the twin peaks model, one body handles prudential safety and another handles conduct. Australia adopted it in 1998, and the United Kingdom split its old Financial Services Authority in 2013 into the Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority.
Some markets also rely on self-regulatory organizations, which write and enforce rules for their members under the oversight of a public regulator.
Independence and accountability
Most countries give financial regulators a degree of independence from day-to-day politics, so that licensing and enforcement decisions are not swayed by lobbying or the electoral cycle. Independence is usually balanced by accountability: regulators are created by statute, have defined objectives, publish annual reports and appear before parliamentary committees. Many are funded by fees or levies on the firms they supervise rather than by taxes. Decisions on individual firms can often be appealed to a tribunal or court, and regulators normally consult the public before making major new rules. Staff may be barred from joining regulated firms for a period after leaving, to reduce conflicts of interest.
International coordination
Because finance crosses borders, national regulators work through international standard-setters. The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision sets bank capital standards, IOSCO covers securities, the IAIS covers insurance, and the FATF sets anti-money laundering standards. The Financial Stability Board, created in 2009, coordinates their work for the G20. Regulators also sign memoranda of understanding to share information and supervise cross-border groups together.
Criticism
Regulators are criticised both for doing too little and for doing too much. "Regulatory capture" describes a regulator that comes to serve the firms it oversees. Failures before the 2008 financial crisis led to sweeping reforms, while fintech and crypto firms often complain of slow licensing and unclear rules. Tools such as the regulatory sandbox were introduced partly in response. Overlapping mandates are another complaint: in fragmented systems such as the US, a single firm may answer to several federal and state agencies with differing views.